Benutzer Diskussion:CorbieVreccan
Letzter Kommentar: vor 4 Jahren von Stefan64 in Abschnitt Wolf-Dieter Storl
Wolf-Dieter Storl[Quelltext bearbeiten]
Please elaborate on your reasoning to delete part of the article, thanks. Stefan64 (Diskussion) 22:52, 25. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- Many of these claims are only sourced to the BLP subject himself. For instance his claims to have worked with the Cheyenne people, but no third-party sources back this. Many of these sorts of statements on his part lack third-party sourcing. CorbieVreccan (Diskussion) 23:41, 25. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- Well, you deleted that Storl taught at Sheridan College from 1984 to 1985. You did not delete that he was a visiting scholar at Benares Hindu University from 1982 to 1984, although this is also referenced by one of his books. Makes no sense. If you don't have evidence that this man is a liar, you should not selectively delete information. Stefan64 (Diskussion) 00:15, 26. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- I am not fluent in German, and I'm not going to edit-war. On en-wiki, we require third-party sourcing for these things. The article needs better sourcing, including his many biographical claims. Especially when he does not have sources in America backing up what he says he did in America. If he's notable, there should be no problem sourcing this adequately. CorbieVreccan (Diskussion) 00:46, 26. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- His time in Wyoming and contact with the Cheyenne ist mentioned in this artice, for example. Stefan64 (Diskussion) 02:26, 26. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- I am not fluent in German, and I'm not going to edit-war. On en-wiki, we require third-party sourcing for these things. The article needs better sourcing, including his many biographical claims. Especially when he does not have sources in America backing up what he says he did in America. If he's notable, there should be no problem sourcing this adequately. CorbieVreccan (Diskussion) 00:46, 26. Jan. 2020 (CET)
- Well, you deleted that Storl taught at Sheridan College from 1984 to 1985. You did not delete that he was a visiting scholar at Benares Hindu University from 1982 to 1984, although this is also referenced by one of his books. Makes no sense. If you don't have evidence that this man is a liar, you should not selectively delete information. Stefan64 (Diskussion) 00:15, 26. Jan. 2020 (CET)