Alaska Public Safety Commissioner dismissal and Template:Toby Keith: Difference between pages

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Difference between pages)
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Jossi (talk | contribs)
72,880 edits
rm weseasl words
 
add
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Navbox Musical artist
The '''Alaska Public Safety Commissioner dismissal''', also known as '''Troopergate''',<ref>The term "Troopergate" has appeared in (among others) the ''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'' [http://www.adn.com/news/politics/story/510080.html], ''[[U.S. News & World Report]]'' [http://www.usnews.com/blogs/erbe/2008/08/29/palin-could-help-mccain-attract-hillary-supporters-if-she-can-address-troopergate.html] and ''[[The New York Times]]''[http://egan.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/29/ms-alaska/?scp=3&sq=troopergate&st=cse]. Other unrelated uses of the word [[Troopergate]] have involved [[Bill Clinton]] ([[Paula Jones]]) and [[Eliott Spitzer]] ([[Eliot Spitzer political surveillance controversy|political surveillance controversy]]).</ref> involves the July 2008 firing of the Public Safety Commissioner for the [[Alaska|State of Alaska]] by [[List of Governors of Alaska|Governor]] [[Sarah Palin]].
| name = Toby Keith
| title = [[Toby Keith]]
| background = solo_singer


| group1 = Studio albums
Palin, who in late August became the [[Republican Party (United States)|Republican]] [[Vice President of the United States|vice presidential]] nominee in the [[United States presidential election, 2008|2008 United States presidential election]], said that she dismissed commissioner [[Walt Monegan]] because of performance-related issues. Monegan said that his dismissal may have been tied to his reluctance to fire Mike Wooten, an [[Alaska State Troopers|Alaska State Trooper]] who is also Palin's ex-brother-in-law. Monegan alleged that the Governor herself, her husband, and members of her staff as well as the state's Attorney General, had contacted him numerous times regarding Wooten. At the time Palin dismissed Monegan, Wooten was involved in a custody battle with his former wife, Molly McCann, Palin's sister.<ref name="Sean" />
| list1 ={{nowrap begin}}''[[Toby Keith (album)|Toby Keith]]''{{·w}} ''[[Boomtown (album)|Boomtown]]''{{·w}} ''[[Blue Moon (Toby Keith album)|Blue Moon]]''{{·w}} ''[[Dream Walkin']]''{{·w}} ''[[How Do You Like Me Now?!]]''{{·w}} ''[[Pull My Chain]]''{{·w}} ''[[Unleashed (Toby Keith album)|Unleashed]]''{{·w}} ''[[Shock'n Y'all]]''{{·w}} ''[[Honkytonk University]]''{{·w}} ''[[White Trash with Money]]''{{·w}} ''[[Big Dog Daddy]]''{{·w}}''[[That Don't Make Me a Bad Guy]]''{{nowrap end}}


| group2 = Compilation albums
Palin denied that there had been any pressure on Monegan to fire Wooten, either from herself or from anyone in her administration.<ref>{{Citation| title = Exclusive: Chief Fired by Palin Speaks Out | newspaper = [[The Washington Post]] | year = 2008 | date = August 29, 2008| url = http://voices.washingtonpost.com/washingtonpostinvestigations/2008/08/exclusive_chief_fired_by_palin.html?hpid=topnews}}</ref> In mid-August, Palin acknowledged that "pressure could have been perceived to exist, although I have only now become aware of it."<ref name="emails" /> She also apologized to Alaskans for what she called "this distraction."<ref>[http://community.adn.com/node/128984 “Raw feed: Palin (Updated)”], ''Anchorage Daily News'' (([[2008-08-13]]).</ref><ref>[http://community.adn.com/adn/node/128981 "Namely, specifically, most disturbing, is a telephone recording apparently made and preserved by the troopers..."], ''Anchorage Daily News'' ([[2008-08-13]]).</ref>
| list2 ={{nowrap begin}}''[[Greatest Hits Volume One (Toby Keith album)|Greatest Hits, Vol. 1]]''{{·w}} ''[[20th Century Masters (Toby Keith album)|20th Century Masters: The Millennium Collection]]''{{·w}} ''[[Greatest Hits 2 (Toby Keith album)|Greatest Hits 2]]''{{·w}} ''[[35 Biggest Hits]]''{{nowrap end}}


| group3 = Christmas albums
Before Palin became governor, she and other members of her family had made various allegations of misconduct against Wooten. An internal investigation upheld some charges and rejected others. On March 1, 2006 the chief of the Alaska state police issued a letter of reprimand to Wooten, and he served a five-day suspension as penalty. After Palin became governor in December 2006, she, her husband [[Todd Palin]], and various aides had further contacts with Monegan about Wooten. Monegan told both Sarah Palin and Todd Palin that the disciplinary proceeding against Wooten was concluded and could not be reopened.
| list3 ={{nowrap begin}}''[[Christmas to Christmas]]''{{·w}} ''[[A Classic Christmas (Toby Keith album)|A Classic Christmas]]''{{nowrap end}}


| group4 = No. 1 Hits
Palin was investigated by an independent investigator, hired by a unanimous vote of a bipartisan committee of the [[Alaska Legislature]],<ref name="HiredHelp">{{cite news|url=http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/478090.html | title=Hired help will probe Monegan dismissal | author=Loy, Wesley | publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'' | date=2008-07-29 | accessdate=2008-08-29}}</ref> "to investigate the circumstances … surrounding [Monegan's termination], and potential abuses of power and/or improper actions by members of the executive branch."<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/><ref >{{cite news | first=Steven | last=Quinn | title=Palin says staffer pressed trooper firing | date=[[2008-08-13]] | publisher=[[Associated Press]] | url =http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/state/20080813-1956-wst-moneganfiring.html | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref><ref >{{cite news | first=Frank | last=James | title=McCain-Palin ticket hits Alaska iceberg | date=[[2008-07-31]] | publisher=[[The Chicago Tribune]] | url =http://www.swamppolitics.com/news/politics/blog/2008/07/mccainpalin_ticket_hits_iceber.html | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref> Palin denied any wrongdoing. [[Democratic Party (United States)|Democratic]] state Senator [[Hollis French]], who is overseeing the investigation, stated the report will "likely be damaging" to the Palin administration, and may be an [[October surprise]].<ref name="Isikoff">Isikoff, Michael and Hosenball, Mark. [http://www.newsweek.com/id/157439/page/1 “Team McCain and the Trooper”], ''[[Newsweek]]'' ([[2008-09-05]]). Also see Ross, Brian and Tepper, Len. [http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/Story?id=5702697&page=1 “'October Surprise' Over Palin Investigation?”] [[ABC News]] ([[2008-09-02]]): "'It's likely to be damaging to the Governor's administration,' said Senator Hollis French, a Democrat… 'She has a credibility problem,' he said…. 'Now they may have to deal with an October surprise,' he said…."</ref> In response to those remarks by French, Republican state Senator John Coghill pushed an unsuccessful effort to have French removed from managing the investigation.<ref name="Isikoff" /><ref name="abcnews9-6">
| list4 ={{nowrap begin}}"[[Should've Been a Cowboy]]"{{·w}} "[[Who's That Man]]"{{·w}} "[[Me Too (song)|Me Too]]"{{·w}} "[[How Do You Like Me Now?! (song)|How Do You Like Me Now?!]]"{{·w}} "You Shouldn't Kiss Me Like This"{{·w}} "I'm Just Talkin' About Tonight"{{·w}} "[[I Wanna Talk About Me]]"{{·w}} "[[My List (song)|My List]]"{{·w}} "[[Courtesy of the Red, White, & Blue (The Angry American)|Courtesy of the Red, White, & Blue]]"{{·w}} "Who's Your Daddy?"{{·w}} "[[Beer for My Horses]]"{{·w}} "[[I Love This Bar]]"{{·w}} "[[American Soldier]]"{{·w}} "[[Whiskey Girl]]"{{·w}} "[[As Good as I Once Was]]"{{·w}} "[[Love Me If You Can]]"{{nowrap end}}
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=5742705
|title=McCain Ally in Alaska Criticizes Troopergate Investigation
|date=2008-09-06
}}
</ref>
Palin's attorney general announced on October 5, 2008 that seven state employees will now honor subpoenas to testify in the legislative investigation of the Troopergate affair.<ref name="adn10-06">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.adn.com/troopergate/story/546971.html
|title=Attorney General says 7 will now testify
|date=2008-10-06
|work=ADN
}}</ref>


| group5 = Related articles
On October 10, 2008, the Republican-dominated Alaska Legislative Council unanimously voted to release the Branchflower investigative report<ref name="Branchflower report">{{cite web|url=http://download2.legis.state.ak.us/DOWNLOAD.pdf | title=Stephen Branchflower report to the Legislative Council | author=Branchflower, Stephen | publisher= State of Alaska Legislature | date=2008-10-10| accessdate=2008-10-10}}</ref> which found that Sarah Palin "abused her power"<ref>Branchflower Report, page 8.</ref> as governor and violated Alaska's Ethics Act in pressuring Monegan to fire Wooten,<ref name="Rood1010">{{cite news | url=http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=6004368&page=1 | title=Troopergate Report: Palin Abused Power: Unanimous but Contentious Vote to Release the Report to the Public | author=Justin Rood and Jessica Rutherford | publisher=ABC News | date =2008-10-10 | accessdate=2008-10-10}}</ref> and that terminating Monegan was "a proper and lawful exercise" of her authority as governor.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.adn.com/palin/story/552393.html|title=Troopergate report: Palin abused power|last=Hunter|first=Don|date=2008-10-10|accessdate=2008-10-10}}</ref>
| list5 = [[Toby Keith discography|Discography]]{{·w}}[[Show Dog Nashville]]{{·w}}''[[Beer for My Horses (film)|Beer for My Horses]]''

}}<noinclude>
==State Trooper Mike Wooten==
[[Category:Country singers templates|Keith, Toby]]
=== Background ===
</noinclude>

In 1999, Sarah Palin's sister Molly McCann and Mike Wooten began dating.<ref name="wall2"/> In 2000, Palin wrote a character reference for Wooten.<ref name="characterreference">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0721/20080721_111415_PalinLetterofRecomend.pdf
|title=Character reference
|first=Sarah
|last=Palin
|date=2000-01-01
}}
</ref> In 2001, Wooten became an Alaska State Trooper.<ref name="Demer727"/> Also in 2001, McCann and Wooten got married. In January 2005, they were separated.<ref name="wall2"/>

=== Divorce filing and police complaint ===
On April 11, 2005, McCann filed for divorce from Wooten.<ref name="docket">{{cite web |title=Alaska Trial Court Cases -- Mccann, Molly J vs. Wooten, Michael G.R. |url=http://www.courtrecords.alaska.gov/pa/pa.urd/pamw2000.docket_lst?68657988 |accessdate=2008-09-01 }}</ref> That day a judge granted a Domestic Violence Protection Order (DVPO) against Wooten. The same day, McCann's father Chuck Heath phoned police to inform them about the DVPO.<ref name="waldron">
{{cite web
|title=Memorandum of Complaint
|first=Burke
|last=Waldron
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/07/25/20/Complaint_memo_against_Wooten_4-1-05.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|date=2005-04-11
|accessdate=2008-09-02
}}</ref><ref name="wall"/>

Also that day, police spoke with McCann. She said Wooten had threatened to shoot her father if he hired an attorney to help in her divorce.<ref name="waldron"/><ref name="wall"/><ref name="grimaldi"/> McCann said that although Wooten "has never physically abused her," he "acts very intimidating."<ref name="waldron"/> She also accused him of using illegal testosterone supplements, drunk driving, and threatening to "take down" Palin if she got involved. McCann said she was "scared" of what Wooten "would do when he finds out she has hired an attorney."<ref name="waldron"/>

===Police investigation into allegations===
Based on McCann's complaint, the Alaska State Troopers began an investigation into the claims made. More than fifteen witnesses were interviewed.<ref name="wall"/>

In May 2005, Sarah Palin told police that she and her son Track had overheard a [[death threat]] against her father (Heath), in February 2005, when McCann had allowed her to listen in on an argument through a phone line (speakerphone).<ref name="transcript">
{{cite web
|title=Transcription of interview with Sarah Palin, May 2 2005
|first=B
|last=Olrun
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/07/18/13/071607-palin-monegue-050205-interview-transcript.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|date=2005-05-02
|accessdate=2008-09-02
}}</ref>

Palin said she had not called the police at that time because she did not want to put Wooten's career in jeopardy, and the situation had not progressed to physical violence.<ref name="grimaldi"/> On August 10, 2005, Palin sent an email to Col. Julia Grimes, chief of the Alaska state police, urging that Wooten be dismissed and giving more details about the alleged death threat.<ref name="palinemailtogrimes">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0717/20080717_064401_645.pdf
|title=Email
|first=Sarah
|last=Palin
|date=2005-08-10
}}
</ref> The email from Palin to Grimes said that the February 2005 threat by Wooten to shoot Heath came after McCann had accused Wooten of attending an event with another woman.<ref name="grimaldi"/><ref name="palinemailtogrimes"/> In the email, Palin described Wooten as "a loose cannon" and "a ticking timebomb," and said that failing to fire Wooten "would lead a rational person to believe there is a problem inside the organization."<ref name="grimaldi">
{{cite news
|title=Long-Standing Feud in Alaska Embroils Palin
|publisher=Washington Post
|first= James V.
|last=Grimaldi
|coauthors= Kimberly Kindy
|date=2008-08-31
|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/30/AR2008083002366.html?hpid=topnews
|accessdate=2008-08-31
}}
</ref><ref name="palinemailtogrimes"/>

As a result of the email, Palin was interviewed again by state troopers on August 18, 2005. During this interview, she stated that she did not warn her father Heath of the death threat until two weeks after it was made; she explained the delay by saying that Wooten had no reason to shoot Heath.<ref name="reinterview">
{{cite web
|title=Re-interview: Sarah Palin
|first=Ron
|last=Wall
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/07/18/12/071608-palin-monegue-sarahtodd-interview.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|accessdate=2008-09-05
|date=2005-08-18
}}</ref><ref name="wall"/> According to Heath himself, the delay was a month: "Heath stated that his daughters didn't report the incident to him until a month later."<ref name="wall2"/>

===Divorce proceedings===

On May 9, a court hearing was held regarding the DVPO. At this hearing the DVPO was quashed because McCann's counsel was unable to produce evidence of any acts of physical or implied violence.<ref name="wall2"/><ref name="wall"/>

In October 2005, the divorce went to trial. During the trial, Judge John Suddock expressed puzzlement at the efforts of McCann's family to get Wooten fired, since it would harm his earning capacity and damage his ability to pay child support. Judge Suddock said "it appears for the world that Ms. McCann and her family have decided to take off for the guy's livelihood -- that the bitterness of whatever who did what to whom has overridden good judgment." A representative for the Alaska State Trooper's union testified that the union viewed the dozen complaints filed by McCann and her family against Wooten as "not job-related" and "harassment." Judge Suddock repeatedly warned McCann and her family to stop "disparaging" Wooten's reputation or risk the judge granting Wooten custody of the children.<ref name="Newsweek">{{cite news | url=http://www.newsweek.com/id/158140/page/1 | title=Warned by the Court | work=Newsweek | author=Hosenball, Mark | date=2008-09-09 | accessdate=2008-09-09}}</ref><ref name="grimaldi"/> At a court hearing in October 2005, Judge Suddock said "disparaging will not be tolerated—it is a form of child abuse … relatives cannot disparage either. If occurs [sic] the parent needs to set boundaries for their relatives."<ref name=Newsweek/>

In the divorce decree that was granted on January 31, 2006,<ref name="docket"/> Judge Suddock expressed concern about continued criticism by McCann's family towards Wooten and noted that he would pay particular attention to problems raised by a custody investigator.<ref name=Newsweek/> Legal disputes between Wooten and McCann over custody, child support and visitation rights continued through 2007 and 2008.<ref name="docket"/>

===Results of internal police investigation===
====Death threat====
On March 1, 2006, Wooten was notified of the results of the Alaska State Trooper internal investigation. The probe found that Wooten violated internal policy, but not the law, in making a death threat against Heath.<ref name="wall"/> Wooten denied having made the threat, but the investigation decided that he had in fact done so.<ref name="wall"/> The investigation concluded that the death threat was not a crime because Wooten did not threaten the father directly; therefore, the investigator deemed the threat to be a violation of trooper policy rather than a violation of criminal law.<ref name="Sean" /> Although the death threat was listed as a violation of trooper policy in the Memorandum of Findings<ref name="wall"/> issued on October 29, 2005, it was not mentioned at all in the suspension letter<ref name="suspensionletter"/> sent to Wooten by Col. Grimes on March 1, 2006.

====Moose hunt====
The investigation found that Wooten had committed a hunting violation in shooting a moose without a permit: he had been out hunting with McCann in September 2003 and had shot the animal himself even though their permit was in McCann's name only.<ref name="wall"/> According to subsequent news reports, McCann had obtained the permit but balked at killing the moose herself, so she handed the gun to her then-husband, who shot the animal.<ref name="WP-30Aug2008">{{cite news |title=Palin Focus of Probe In Police Chief's Firing: Her Family Wanted a Trooper Dismissed, He Says | url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/29/AR2008082903598_3.html?hpid=topnews&sid=ST2008083000375&s_pos= |author= James V. Grimaldi and Kimberly Kindy | publisher= [[Washington Post]] |date= 2008-08-30 }} </ref>

====Taser incident====
Wooten was also found to have violated department policy in using a [[Taser]] on his then 11-year old stepson in 2003. He told investigators that he did so "in a training capacity" after the child had asked to be tased.<ref name="Demer727"/><ref name="wall">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0717/20080717_062016_641.pdf
|title=Memorandum of Findings
|first=Ronald
|last=Wall
|date=2005-10-29
}}</ref><ref>In a September 2008 newspaper interview, Wooten said that he set the Taser to "test" mode, meaning that it was on low power. Wooten added that he attached clips to the child's shirt rather than firing darts from a gun, that he turned on the power for less than one second, and that afterwards his stepson "thought it was great and wanted to do it all over again." He stated that "everyone laughed about" the incident at the time. {{cite news
|title=Palin's Ex-Brother-in-Law Says He Regrets Bad Blood
|first=James W.
|last=Grimaldi
|work=Washington Post
|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/05/AR2008090503407.html
|date=2008-09-06
|accessdate=2008-09-06
}}</ref><ref>According to a spokesman for Taser International, "if the Taser is fired for just a second, it would feel like your funny bone was hit." {{cite news
|title= Is Wooten a good trooper?
|first=Lisa
|last=Demer
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|url=http://www.adn.com/politics/story/476430.html
|date=2008-07-27
|accessdate=2008-09-06
}}
</ref> In a statement to police, the boy said "he wanted to be tased to show that he's not a mommy's boy in front of Bristol [his cousin, Palin's daughter]. Following being tased he went upstairs to tell his mother that he was fine."<ref name="wall2"/> In a statement to police, Molly McCann said "she was up stairs giving a bath to the kids … Mike was going to show Payton what it feels like and she told Mike that he better not."<ref name="wall2"/> According to Molly's account, she remained upstairs during the incident.

Although the Taser incident happened in 2003, it was not reported to police until on or after April 11, 2005, the day McCann filed for divorce. On June 6, 2005, a police investigator asked Bristol why they "waited so long and brought the incident up after two years." Bristol said "because of the divorce."<ref name="wall2"/>

====Alcohol-related allegations====
The investigation initially cleared Wooten on all of the alcohol-related charges,<ref name="wall"/> but Grimes overturned that result and found that Wooten did "take [an] open beer with him when he drove away in his trooper vehicle" on one occasion in the summer of 2004, violating both the law and internal trooper policy.<ref name="grimes">
{{cite url
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/07/25/20/Memo_overturning_findings_2-1-06.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|title=Memorandum
|first=Julia
|last=Grimes
|date=2005-10-29
}}
</ref> Wooten was not on duty; he was wearing "civilian attire." And he "drove approximately one mile to his residence."<ref name="wall2">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0717/20080717_061848_639.pdf
|title=Police interviews
|first=Ron
|last=Wall
|date=2005-05-01
}}
</ref> Because Wooten "was a member of the SERT [SWAT] team … he [was allowed to] use his State vehicle for personal use."<ref name="wall3">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0717/20080717_062147_642.pdf
|title=Transcript
|first=Ron
|last=Wall
|date=2005-08-18
}}</ref> The only witnesses to this event were close friends of Sarah Palin's father: "Adrian Lane was a student of Chuck Heath's in Idaho when he was a child and they have been close friends ever since."<ref name="wall"/> This is apparently why the original Memorandum of Findings<ref name="wall"/> treated this allegation as "Not Sustained." Wooten denied this allegation.<ref name="wall2"/>

====Other charges====
Wooten was cleared of numerous other allegations made by McCann and her family, including that he had taken illegal [[steroid]] and [[testosterone]] supplements, that he had physically assaulted McCann, and that he had illegally shot a [[wolf]].<ref name="wall"/>

Aside from the alleged death threat against Heath, Sarah and Molly had also accused Wooten of making threats that he would "bring down" Sarah and her family. Sarah Palin had no first-hand knowledge of these threats; she had heard about them via Molly. Molly told police she understood Wooten to mean that he could use his position as a trooper to make life difficult for Sarah. Wooten denied making this threat. The police investigation treated this allegation as "Not Sustained."<ref name="wall"/>

===Suspension of Wooten===
Based on the internal investigation findings, Grimes announced on March 1, 2006 that she would suspend Wooten for ten days. In announcing the suspension, Grimes referred to the Taser, moose and beer incidents, and also to seven other negative actions in Wooten's personnel file, such as failing to use turn signals. She concluded that "[t]he record clearly indicates a serious and concentrated pattern of unacceptable and at times, illegal activity occurring over a lengthy period, which establishes a course of conduct totally at odds with the ethics of our profession".<ref name="grimaldi"/><ref name="Demer727">{{Citation| last = Demer| first = Lisa | title = Is Wooten a good trooper?| newspaper = [[Anchorage Daily News]]| year = 2008| date = July 27, 2008| url = http://www.adn.com/politics/story/476430.html}}</ref><ref name="suspensionletter">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0717/20080717_061601_637.pdf
|title=Suspension letter
|first=Julia P.
|last=Grimes
|date=2006-03-01
}}
</ref> After a [[trade union|union]] protest, the suspension was reduced to five days, and Wooten was warned by Grimes that he would be fired if he committed any further misconduct.<ref name="Demer727">{{cite news|last=Demer|first=Lisa|url=http://www.adn.com/politics/story/476430.html|title=Is Wooten a good trooper?|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-07-27).</ref>

==Contacts between Governor's office and Wooten's supervisors==
In early December 2006, Palin took office as Governor of Alaska and appointed [[Walt Monegan|Walter C. Monegan III]] to be Public Safety Commissioner, a cabinet position.<ref name="grimaldi"/> Monegan is a former police chief of [[Anchorage, Alaska|Anchorage]] and son of [[Walter C. Monegan, Jr.]]<ref>[http://www.muni.org/apd1/chiefs.cfm "APD Chiefs of Police"].</ref> According to the investigator hired by the state legislature, "right about that time, a little after the swearing in," someone from Palin's office called Monegan's office to schedule a meeting between Monegan and [[Todd Palin]], the governor's husband.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/>

According to Monegan, the meeting took place in the Governor's office on January 4, 2007, with only Monegan and Todd Palin present. Palin asked Monegan to look into the Wooten affair. He gave Monegan various records, including material from a private investigator hired by the Palin family. Palin said that he disagreed with the five-day suspension, as inadequate and insufficient,<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/> and accused Wooten of a variety of transgressions, including drunken driving and child abuse.<ref name="NYT-30Aug08">{{cite news | first=Michael | last=Luo | title=Investigators Are Looking at Governor About Firing | date=[[2008-08-29]] | publisher=[[New York Times]] | url =http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/30/us/politics/30trooper.html | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref> He asked Monegan to revisit the matter in light of some additional evidence he was providing. Monegan agreed to do that. He detailed some staff for the review, who made a page-by-page comparison with the investigation that had been done earlier, and told Monegan that there was nothing new.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/> Monegan then told Todd Palin that there was nothing he could do as the case was closed.<ref name="grimaldi"/> The troopers operate under a union contract that restricts the circumstances under which a trooper can be fired.<ref name="newyorker"/>

According to Monegan, Governor Palin raised the matter with him personally twice, in January and February,<ref>Excerpt from Washington Post: The governor raised the issue again in February 2007 during the legislative session in Juneau. "As we were walking down the stairs in the capitol building," Monegan said, "she wanted to talk to me about her former brother-in-law. I said, 'Ma'am, I need to keep you at arm's length with this. I can't deal about him with you. If need be, I can talk to Todd." {{cite news |title=Palin Focus of Probe In Police Chief's Firing: Her Family Wanted a Trooper Dismissed, He Says | url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/29/AR2008082903598_3.html?hpid=topnews&sid=ST2008083000375&s_pos= |author= James V. Grimaldi and Kimberly Kindy | publisher= ''Washington Post'' |date= August 30, 2008 }}</ref> and then kept raising the matter indirectly through e-mails, though she did not again bring it up directly.<ref name="grimaldi"/> In an email sent to Monegan on February 7, 2007 about a proposed bill to require 99-year sentences for police officers found guilty of murder, Palin mentioned Wooten as an example of an officer who violated the public trust.<ref name="emails"/> The email listed several examples of Wooten's alleged misbehavior.<ref name="emails">
{{cite news
|title=Palin E-Mails Show Intense Interest in Trooper's Penalty
|first=James V.
|last=Grimaldi
|coauthors=Karl Vick
|date=2008-09-04
|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/03/AR2008090303210_pf.html
|accessdate=2008-09-03
}}
</ref> Another Palin email, dated July 17, 2007, concerned a proposed bill to keep guns out of the hands of the mentally ill. Palin wrote to Monegan that her first thoughts "went to my ex-brother-in-law, the trooper, who threatened to kill my dad yet was not even reprimanded by his bosses and still to this day carries a gun, of course."<ref name="emails"/> A spokesperson for the McCain-Palin campaign says that Palin's contacts with Monegan were only made in order to alert him to potential threats to her family.<ref name="grimaldi" />

Monegan also has said he got telephone calls from three Palin appointees: her then-chief of staff, Mike Tibbles; Commissioner Annette Kreitzer of the Department of Administration; and Attorney General [[Talis Colberg]]. Colberg said he called after Todd Palin asked him about "the process" for handling death threats made by state troopers against the first family; Colberg was told by Monegan that the matter had been handled, and Colberg reported back to Todd Palin that nothing more could be done.<ref name="grimaldi"/> In mid-August 2008, the Alaska Attorney General's inquiry reported that Palin's staff had made about two dozen contacts with public safety officials about Wooten, in 2007 and 2008, with more than half initiated by Tibbles.<ref name="Sean"/>

In April 2007, Todd Palin told the ''Anchorage Daily News'' that he had met once with Wooten's supervisor, Colonel Audie Holloway, to give her pictures of Wooten driving a snowmobile when he was out on a worker's compensation claim.<ref name="grimaldi"/> Diane Kiesel, Alaska state personnel director, also called Holloway about the snowmobile incident.<ref>Alaska Deputy Attorney General Michael Barnhill said on August 30, 2008, that Kiesel called because she believed the troopers should know there might be a violation of law. "People in the administration made contact with the Department of Public Safety to deal with the worker's compensation file," Barnhill said. He also said that the attorney general's office did not think the governor's staff should be banned from making calls about Wooten to his superiors. ({{cite news
|title=Long-Standing Feud in Alaska Embroils Palin
|publisher=Washington Post
|first= James V.
|last=Grimaldi
|coauthors= Kimberly Kindy
|date=2008-08-31
|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/30/AR2008083002366.html?hpid=topnews
|accessdate=2008-08-31
}})</ref>

On November 19, 2007, a meeting was called by Mike Tibbles, at the time Palin's chief of staff, to discuss the process of how Wooten had returned to work after a worker's compensation injury. Present were Kevin Brooks, the deputy commissioner of the Department of Administration, Nicki Neal, director of the Personnel Division, and Diane Kiesel, former director of Personnel and Labor Relations.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/> [[Image:Nowhere 99901 (Crop2).jpg|thumb|left|Ivy Frye, special assistant to Palin, subpoenaed in '''Troopergate'''.<ref>Matt Volz and Gene Johnson, [http://news.yahoo.com/story//ap/20080920/ap_on_el_pr/palin_troopergate_investigation "Stalled Troopergate probe leaves many questions"], ''Associated Press'', September 20, 2008</ref>
]]

On February 29, 2008, Frank Bailey, the governor's director of boards and commissions, made a phone call to trooper Lt. Rodney Dial, the state troopers' liaison to the Legislature. The Public Safety Department recorded the call, as it does routinely, and the Palin administration released an audiotape of it on August 13.<ref name="Sean"/><ref name="PR-13Aug08">[http://www.gov.state.ak.us/news-60642.html "Governor to Turn Over Findings"], Department of Law press release with link to audio of Bailey call], August 13, 2008</ref> In it, Bailey made several accusations against Wooten, including that he lied on his application to become a trooper. He was recorded saying "Todd and Sarah are scratching their heads, 'why on earth hasn't, why is this guy still representing the department?' "<ref name="Sean"/> and "I'm telling you honestly, you know, she really likes Walt [Monegan] a lot, but on this issue, she feels like it's, she doesn't know why there is absolutely no action for a year on this issue. It's very, very troubling to her and the family. I could definitely relay that."<ref name="Sean"/> Bailey said in an interview on August 13 that no one had asked him to make the call and he didn't know why he indicated in the call that he was speaking on behalf of the Palins.<ref name="Sean" /> A transcript of the call is available.<ref name="baileytranscript">
{{cite url
|url=http://consortiumnews.com/EthicsDocument.pdf
|title=Transcript of Bailey/Dial phone call, with PSEA complaint letter
|first=Frank
|last=Bailey
|date=2008-02-29
}}
</ref>

Cell records show that [[Todd Palin]] spoke to Palin aide Ivy Frye three times on the afternoon of Feb. 28, the day before Bailey's conversation with Dial. About three hours after the last call, the first of ten emails began to circulate between Ivy Frye, [[Sarah Palin]], her husband Todd, Bailey, Administration Commissioner Annette Kreitzer, Deputy Chief of Staff Randy Ruaro and Palin aide Kris Perry. The exchanges continued overnight and into the morning of Bailey's phone call.<ref>Only these seven contributors, and the subject lines of the emails were released under a public records request. The emails have the subject line "PSEA," referring to the troopers' union: the Public Safety Employees Association, which was in the midst of contract negotiations with the state. Palin will not release the contents of those emails, despite her claim that Alaska's government is open and transparent. They — along with more than one thousand other messages — are included in an exemption in the state's open records law. (Matt Volz and Gene Johnson, [http://news.yahoo.com/story//ap/20080920/ap_on_el_pr/palin_troopergate_investigation "Stalled Troopergate probe leaves many questions"], ''Associated Press'', September 20, 2008</ref>

==Dismissal of Public Safety Commissioner Walter Monegan==
On July 11, 2008, Palin's acting chief of staff Mike Nizich dismissed Monegan, offering him a position as executive director of the state Alcoholic Beverage Control Board, which he turned down.<ref name=monegan>{{cite news | first=Kyle | last=Hopkins | title=State's top cop, Walt Monegan, is fired | date=[[2008-07-12]] | publisher=[[The McClatchy Company]] | url =http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/story/463204.html | work =''Anchorage Daily News'' | accessdate = 2008-08-21}}</ref>

In a letter to DPS employees announcing his termination, Monegan wrote that he was an [[At-will employment|at-will employee]] and knew his dismissal was "a possibility ever present," and that he had been advised that the governor wanted to take DPS in a "different direction."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.ktuu.com/Global/story.asp?S=8672313|title=Monegan's farewell letter to DPS employees, July 2008|publisher= KTUU.com|accessdate=2008-09-04}}</ref> In an interview the next day Monegan said that the dismissal had come "out of the blue" and that "[i]f the governor was upset with me for one thing or another, it had never been communicated to me."<ref name="monegan"/>

On July 17, Palin said publicly that "We have [to] start recruiting. We have to start doing more than just talking about it. And taking action also." Monegan responded on July 18 that the two most recent trooper graduating classes had the most recruits in years.<ref name="KVTA-19Jul08">{{cite news | first=Matthew | last=Simon | title=Monegan says Palin administration and first gentleman used governor's office to pressure firing first family's former brother-in-law | date=2008-07-19 | publisher=[[KTVA|CBS 11]] | url =http://www.ktva.com/ci_9929780?source=most_viewed | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref> On July 18, Monegan suggested that his dismissal might have been related to his reluctance to fire Wooten. He said phone calls and questions from the Palin administration and the governor's husband, [[Todd Palin]], about Wooten started shortly after Monegan was hired and continued until May or June 2008.<ref name=monegan1>{{cite news | first=Megan | last=Holland | title=Monegan says he was pressured to fire cop | date=[[2008-07-19]] | publisher=[[The McClatchy Company]] | url =http://www.adn.com/politics/story/469135.html | work =''Anchorage Daily News'' | accessdate = 2008-07-22}}: "Monegan said he still isn't sure why he was fired but thought that Wooten could be part of it."</ref> Monegan said that Palin's acting chief of staff, Mike Nizich, told him on July 11 that he was being removed from his position because Palin wanted to take the Department of Public Safety in a different direction.<ref name="ABC-28Aug08"/>

On July 18, in response to Monegan's comments, Palin released a statement: {{cquote|I do not interfere with the day-to-day operations of any department. Former Commissioner Monegan was not released due to any actions or inaction related to personnel issues in his department. We had hoped the former commissioner would have stayed in state service to help fight alcohol-related crime. We offered him the position of executive director of the Alcoholic Beverage Control board and, unfortunately, he turned it down.<ref name="statement"/><ref name="KVTA-19Jul08"/>}} The statement also denied that the governor had improperly accessed Wooten's employment records, saying that "[t]o allege that I, or any member of my family, requested, received or released confidential personnel information on an Alaska State Trooper, or directed disciplinary action be taken against any employee of the Department of Public Safety, is, quite simply, outrageous. Any information regarding personnel records came from the trooper himself."<ref name="statement">
{{cite url
|title=Statement on DPS Commissioner Dismissal
|first=Sarah
|last=Palin
|url=http://gov.state.ak.us/archive-28906.html
|date=2008-07-18
|accessdate=2008-09-10
}}
</ref> Palin said "absolutely no pressure [was] ever put on Commissioner Monegan to hire or fire anybody, at any time … no pressure was ever put on anybody to fire anybody."<ref name="KVTA-19Jul08"/> She also praised Monegan's replacement, saying "Commissioner Kopp shares my vision for filling vacant positions and reducing crime across the state."<ref name="statement"/>

In late July, former [[United States Attorney|U.S. Attorney]] Wevley Shea, who had acted previously as an informal advisor to Palin, wrote her an unsolicited letter in which he urged her to apologize for "overreaching or perceived overreaching" to get Wooten fired, and warned that the matter could snowball into a bigger scandal. The letter said that she should fire any aides who had raised concerns with Monegan.<ref name="WSJ-11Sep08">{{cite news |title=Ethics Adviser Warned Palin About Trooper Issue: Letter Described Situation as 'Grave,' Called for Apology |first=Jim |last=Carlton |publisher = Wall Street Journal | date = September 11, 2008 |url=http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122109403841221751.html?mod=special_page_campaign2008_topbox }}</ref><ref>[http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/11/palin.investigation/?iref=hpmostpop "Palin adviser warned that firing raised 'grave' concern"], [[CNN]] ([[2008-09-11]]):"A former ethics adviser to Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin warned in July that firing her public safety commissioner would become a "grave concern" for her administration....Shea had acted as an informal ethics adviser to Palin, but he told CNN that his advice on the Monegan firing was unsolicited."</ref>

On August 13, Palin said specifically that her action was unrelated to Wooten. She said that Monegan was dismissed for not adequately filling state trooper vacancies and fighting alcohol abuse problems, and because he "did not turn out to be a team player on budgeting issues."<ref name="Sean">{{cite news|last=Cockerham|first=Sean|url=http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/492964.html|title=Palin staff pushed to have trooper fired|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-08-14|accessdate=2008-08-24}}</ref> Palin acknowledged that "pressure could have been perceived to exist, although I have only now become aware of it."<ref name="emails" /> She suspended Frank Bailey, and apologized to Alaskans:

{{cquote|Mr. Bailey was aware of my family’s personal concerns about Trooper Wooten. It appears that he, though, tried to apply some pressure on my behalf and this was without ever discussing it with me and I apologize to Alaskans for this distraction.<ref>[http://community.adn.com/node/128984 “Raw feed: Palin (Updated)”], ''Anchorage Daily News'' (([[2008-08-13]]).</ref><ref name="adn8-13">[http://community.adn.com/adn/node/128981 "Namely, specifically, most disturbing, is a telephone recording apparently made and preserved by the troopers..."], ''Anchorage Daily News'' ([[2008-08-13]]).</ref>}}

On August 28, in an interview with ''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'', Monegan said, "For the record, no one ever said fire Wooten. Not the governor. Not Todd. Not any of the other staff. What they said directly was more along the lines of 'This isn't a person that we would want to be representing our state troopers.' "<ref>{{cite news|last=Demer|first=Lisa|url=http://www.adn.com/sarahpalin/story/510080.html|title='Troopergate' inquiry hangs over campaign|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-08-30|accessdate=2008-09-05}}.</ref> He later added that he had resisted pressure from the Governor and her husband to re-open the case against Wooten.<ref name="Schwartz">{{cite web| last = Schwartz| first = Rhonda| coauthors = Justin Rood| title = Fired Official: Governor Sarah Palin Did Not Tell the Truth to ABC| publisher = [[ABC News]]| date = September 15, 2008| url = http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=5804703&page=1 | accessdate = 2008-09-15}}</ref>

In an August interview with ''[[The New Yorker]]'', Palin blamed Monegan for failing to address alcohol abuse in rural Alaska. According to the ''New Yorker'' article, Palin stated that she didn't fire Monegan, but rather "asked him to drop everything else and single-mindedly take on the state’s drinking problem, as the director of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board." Palin characterized the job offered to Monegan as "commensurate in salary pretty much—ten thousand dollars less," but said that Monegan didn't want it, so he quit.<ref name="newyorker">
{{cite news
|title=Letter from Alaska: The State of Sarah Palin
|first=Philip
|last=Gourevitch
|url=http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2008/09/22/080922fa_fact_gourevitch
|date=2008-09-22
|accessdate=2008-09-12
}}
</ref>

In September, in a televised interview with [[Charles Gibson]] of [[ABC News]], Palin reiterated her position that she had dismissed Monegan because of his job performance and that neither she nor her husband pressured him to fire Wooten. Palin said "I never pressured him to hire or fire anybody … I know that Todd, too, never pressured … Monegan."<ref name="palingibson">
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/Vote2008/Story?id=5789483
|title=Excerpts: Charlie Gibson Interviews GOP Vice Presidential Candidate Sarah Palin
|first=Charlie
|last=Gibson
|date=2008-09-12
}}
</ref> In response, Monegan said: "She's not telling the truth when she told ABC neither she nor her husband pressured me to fire Trooper Wooten. And she's not telling the truth to the media about her reasons for firing me."<ref name="Schwartz"/>

Monegan has made a number of other statements alleging that he had been pressured to fire Wooten. "There was pressure for that, yes."<ref name=monegan2>{{cite news |
first=Corey |
last=Allen-Young |
title=Governor and staff's latest explanations leave more questions |
date=[[2008-08-15]] |
publisher=[[KTVA]] |
url =http://www.ktva.com/ci_10206518 |
accessdate = 2008-09-15}}</ref> "There were numerous contacts by the governor, her husband, by her staff that basically said that Trooper Wooten was not an acceptable example of an Alaska state trooper."<ref name=monegan3>{{cite news |
first=Lisa |
last=Myers |
title=Alaska state legislature investigating whether Palin abused power in firing state employee |
date=[[2008-09-03]] |
publisher=[[NBC Nightly News]] |
url =http://www6.lexisnexis.com/publisher/EndUser?Action=UserDisplayFullDocument&orgId=574&topicId=100007221&docId=l:846024877&start=2 |
accessdate = 2008-09-15}}</ref> "The fact that they tried for better than a year while I was there is kind of indicative that somebody was trying to pressure something."<ref name="monegan1"/>

On September 2, 2008, "a senior strategist in the McCain campaign" said "the man who was fired has said on the record that he was never pressured by the governor or the governor’s husband on the issue of firing Trooper Wooten."<ref name=monegan4>{{cite news |
first=Byron |
last=York |
title=Team McCain Hits Back on Palin, Vetting |
date=[[2008-09-02]] |
publisher=[[National Review]] |
url=http://corner.nationalreview.com/post/?q=N2EyM2Q2NjYxZmUxMzgxNTYwMjAwZDk3MmE2NGNmNjY= |
accessdate = 2008-09-15}}</ref>

On September 15, 2008, McCain/Palin campaign spokeswoman Meg Stapleton held a news conference at which she accused Monegan of "egregious insubordination," "obstructionist conduct" and a "brazen refusal" to follow proper channels for requesting money. Asked why someone with a history of insubordination would be offered the leadership of the Alaska Alcoholic Beverage Control Board, Stapleton said that without having to deal with a budget, Monegan would be able to focus on alcohol abuse issues. She added that Palin "respects the fact that [Monegan] was respected in the community."<ref name="associatedpress9-15">{{cite news
|title=GOP lawmakers sue to stop Palin investigation
|first=Steve
|last=Quinn
|work=Associated Press
|date=2008-09-16
|url=http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5jOTk11gvqDAgD0cY3i4WjI_2YOxwD938160O2
|accessdate=2008-09-16
}}
</ref>

==Investigations and reviews==
The Alaska Legislative Council is a [[Bipartisanship|bipartisan]] body of state House and Senate members who can convene to make decisions when the full Legislature is not in session.<ref name="alaskalegislativecouncil">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.legis.state.ak.us/basis/get_com_info.asp?comm=HLEC&session=25
|title=Official site of Alaska Legislative Council
}}
</ref> As of July 2008 it was made up of four Democrats and eight Republicans.<ref name="associatedpress9-15"/> On July 28, 2008, the Legislative Council voted 12-0 to hire an independent investigator to investigate Palin and her staff for possible abuse of power or improper actions surrounding Monegan's dismissal.<ref name=HiredHelp/> A retired state prosecutor, Stephen Branchflower, was named as the investigator.<ref name="BranchflowerChosen">{{cite news |last = Holland |first = Megan |title = Branchflower will investigate Monegan case |publisher = ''Anchorage Daily News'' |date = [[2008-08-02]] |url = http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/482003.html |accessdate = 2008-08-30 }}</ref> Branchflower was awarded a three-month contract, which began on August 1. In the same unanimous vote, the Council also appointed Sen. French (D), a former state prosecutor, to manage Branchflower.<ref name=HiredHelp/> French is Chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee.<ref>http://www.aksenate.org/index.php?committees=view#6</ref>

===Alaska Attorney General (internal investigation)===
As a result of the announcement of a legislative investigation, [[Talis Colberg]], the Alaskan Attorney General, and his Department of Law, began conducting an inquiry in late July at the request of the Governor.<ref name="AGInquiry">{{cite news |last = Cockerham |first = Sean |title = Palin launches Monegan inquiry ahead of special investigation |publisher = ''Anchorage Daily News'' |date = [[2008-08-13]] |url = http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/492077.html | accessdate = 2008-08-30 }}</ref> Rep. Ramras (R), chair of the House Judiciary Committee, criticized the Colberg probe. "I think it is harmful to the credibility of the administration, harmful to the process and harmful to all the parties involved … it's just the worst possible thing to be doing." Ramras said Colberg "needs to be very careful to avoid his review having any appearance of tampering with witnesses."<ref name="AGInquiry"/> The findings of the review were made public on August 13.<ref name=grimaldi/><ref name="PR-13Aug08"/>

The inquiry identified two dozen contacts by members of Palin's staff with public safety officials, concerning Wooten. Of these, only one was determined to be improper by the Attorney General's office.<ref name="grimaldi"/> Palin said that she had only known about some of the two dozen contacts, and that she never asked anyone on her staff to get in touch with such officials about Wooten.<ref name="contacts">{{cite web|url=http://www.mcclatchydc.com/homepage/story/48172.html |title=Alaska's governor admits her staff tried to have trooper fired |author=Sean Cockerham |publisher=Anchorage Daily News |date=2008-08-14 |accessdate=2008-08-29}}</ref> Additionally, the Governor said that, "Many of these inquiries were completely appropriate. However, the serial nature of the contacts could be perceived as some kind of pressure, presumably at my direction."<ref name="contacts" />

In July, Palin had denied that there had been any pressure on Monegan to fire Wooten, either from herself or from anyone in her administration.<ref>{{Citation| title = Exclusive: Chief Fired by Palin Speaks Out | newspaper = [[The Washington Post]] | year = 2008 | date = August 29, 2008| url = http://voices.washingtonpost.com/washingtonpostinvestigations/2008/08/exclusive_chief_fired_by_palin.html?hpid=topnews}}</ref> Based on the Attorney General's inquiry,<ref name="grimaldi"/> she said on August 13 that "I do now have to tell Alaskans that such pressure could have been perceived to exist although I have only now become aware of it."

Palin said the "most disturbing" contact found in the inquiry by the Attorney General and his office was the February 2008 phone call by Bailey to Dial.<ref name="Sean"/> In a newspaper interview the day after the tape was released, Palin said she never asked Bailey to make the call, which she called "just wrong." She also denied that the tape showed the administration applying pressure to fire Wooten, saying "[i]f that's pressure, then (after) years in law enforcement, how do they do their job if that's perceived as pressure?"<ref>
{{cite news
|title=Palin says staff's calls were not pressure
|work=''Anchorage Daily News''
|date=2008-08-15
|first=Kyle
|last=Hopkins
|coauthors=Sean Cockerham
|url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/494556.html
|accessdate=2008-09-08
}}
</ref> A day or two earlier, Palin had described Bailey's call as a form of pressure: "It appears that he, though, tried to apply some pressure on my behalf."<ref name="adn8-13"/>

On August 19, the Governor's office announced that Bailey had been placed on paid leave, pending the outcome of the legislative investigation. Sharon Leighow, a spokesperson for the governor, said that Bailey was kept on the state payroll so Palin "can direct him to assist Mr. Branchflower, thereby fulfilling her pledge to Alaskans to cooperate fully with the investigation."<ref>{{cite news |first=Kyle |last=Hopkins |title=Palin aide put on leave in firing flap |url=http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/499248.html |work=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'' |date=2008-08-20 |accessdate=2008-08-30 }}</ref><ref name="washingtontimes8-30">Jerry Seper, [http://www.washtimes.com/news/2008/aug/30/palin-aides-welcome-alaska-probe/ "Palin aides welcome Alaska probe: Say governor had no connection to case of sister's ex-husband"], ''Washington Times'', August 30, 2008</ref>

===State Legislature investigation===
On August 16, [[Hollis French]] said that the Palin administration has been cooperating and that subpoenas would not be necessary.<ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/story/495594.html|title=Subpoenas uncalled for in Wooten matter|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-08-16|accessdate=2008-08-24}}</ref> In late August, French said that Palin was likely to be deposed soon in the case.<ref name="ABC-28Aug08">{{cite news|first=Marcus|last=Barum|url=http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=5687512&page=1|title=Palin Could Be Deposed in Probe: Former State Official Claims He Was Pressured to Fire Gov.'s Former Brother-in-Law|publisher=ABC News|date=2008-08-29}}</ref>

In mid-August, Palin hired a private practice lawyer, Thomas Van Flein, to defend her and her staff in the investigation; he began working on August 21.<ref name="ADN-1Sep08b">{{cite news|first=Lisa|last=Demer|url=http://www.adn.com/politics/story/513137.html|title=Attorney challenges Monegan firing inquiry|publisher=''Anchorage Daily News''|date=2008-09-01}}</ref> Van Flein was being paid by the State of Alaska; Attorney General Colberg was unable to represent Palin because of his involvement in the case.<ref>{{cite news | first=Steve | last=Quinn | title=Palin hires attorney for public safety controversy | date=2008-09-01 | publisher=[[The Associated Press]] | url =http://www.ktuu.com/Global/story.asp?S=8933043 | accessdate = 2008-09-01 | quote = Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, the GOP vice presidential candidate, has hired a private practice attorney to defend her and members of her staff in the investigation into the firing of her public safety commissioner.}}</ref> On August 29, Van Flein asked for all witness statements, documents and other materials collected in the course of the legislative investigation. French said, in response, that he had instructed Branchflower not to provide the letters or witness statements.<ref name="ADN-1Sep08a">{{cite news|first=Lisa|last=Demer|url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/512842.html|title=Private lawyer hired to represent Palin in Monegan inquiry|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-09-01}}</ref> On September 17, Van Flein said that he had, as of September 12, terminated his contract with the state, and was representing Todd and Sarah Palin personally. Van Flein said that the state would not be billed for any of his services since he was hired in August.<ref name="adn9-18">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.adn.com/troopergate/story/529607.html
|title=Inquiry into Monegan dismissal heats up
|date=2008-09-18
|publisher=''Anchorage Daily News''
|author=Wesley Loy
}}
</ref> Van Flein said that, after listening to Colberg's interview with Branchflower, he believes that Colberg is not a "material witness."<ref name="adn9-18" />

====Scheduled completion date====
Branchflower's 3-month contract that started on August 1 was originally scheduled to end on October 31, and therefore the investigation was expected to end on that date.<ref name="AP06Aug2008">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2008/09/06/america/NA-POL-US-Palin-Troopergate.php
|title=Subpoenas to be issued for Palin trooper probe
|date=2008-09-06
|work=AP
}}</ref> On September 2, French said the report would "likely to be damaging to the (Palin) administration," and could be an [[October surprise]]. In response to French's statements, Republican state Senator John Coghill launched an unsuccessful attempt to have French removed from overseeing the investigation, and suggested the entire investigation ought to be cancelled, saying "if this has been botched up the way it has, there's a question as to whether it should continue."<ref name="Isikoff" /> French apologized: "I made some remarks I should not have made. The point to remember is I'm not doing the investigation, Steven Branchflower is. He is independently gathering the facts and he will issue the report, which he will have to defend."<ref name="ktuu9-5">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/Global/story.asp?s=8959682
|title=Lawmakers scuffle over Monegan investigation
|date=2008-09-05
}}
</ref>

On September 5 French said that rather than ending on October 31, the Friday before the election, the report would be complete by October 10. House Judiciary Chairman Ramras (R) said the reason for the earlier completion date for the report is to avoid the appearance of a last-minute "October surprise."<ref name="frenchramrasrelease">
{{cite url
|url=http://housemajority.org/item.php?id=item20080905-622
|title=Legislative Leaders Announce Hearing and Vow to Complete Investigation Ahead of Schedule
|date=2008-09-05
}}
</ref> Other Republican lawmakers also expressed support for the earlier date.

French's "October surprise" remarks were used, in part, as the basis for a lawsuit that was brought by five Republican lawmakers, in an attempt to stop the Branchflower investigation.<ref name="RequestForRestrainingOrder">
{{cite web
|title=Request for a temporary restraining order
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/09/27/09/TRO.Memorandum.REVISED_FINAL.09-26-08.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|date=2008-09-26
|accessdate=2008-10-03
}}</ref> On October 2, Superior Court Judge Peter Michalski rejected this lawsuit, and defended French's right to make those remarks: "It is expected that legislators will belong to some party and will support the positions of their party, often publicly. The legislature is, by its nature, a political branch. It would be assumed that, e.g., review of Wall Street's financiers might be founded on a strongly held and expressed belief that somebody did something wrong."<ref name="JudgeMichalskisOrder">
{{cite web
|title=Judge Michalski's order
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/10/03/09/ORDER_on_Motion_to_Dismiss_and_Temporary_and_Preliminary_Injunction.10-02.2008.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|date=2008-10-02
|accessdate=2008-10-03
}}</ref>

====Initial dispute over witnesses' testimony====
On September 1, French said the legislature would pay to fly Branchflower to wherever Sarah Palin was on the campaign trail if needed, and that Branchflower had not yet been able to set up an interview with Palin. In a letter on September 1, Van Flein indicated that Palin probably would not agree to an interview unless the legislature turned the matter over to the Personnel Board.<ref name="ADN-2Sep08">{{cite news|first=Lisa|last=Demer|url=http://www.adn.com/sarah-palin/story/514056.html|title=Palin wants investigation yanked from Legislature|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-09-02}}</ref> If witnesses were not available, French said, he would ask the Senate Judiciary Committee, which he chairs, to issue subpoenas. He said that Palin needed to be interviewed sometime in September.<ref name="ADN-1Sep08b"/>

On September 2, the lawyer for Frank Bailey, the aide Palin suspended after a recording of his call to a trooper official came to light, canceled a deposition scheduled for September 3. The lawyer said that Van Flein, who represents Palin, informed him that there was a jurisdictional dispute that was unsettled. Bailey's lawyer also said that Bailey was ready to be deposed, and that Bailey would say that he wasn't asked by the Governor to make any calls regarding Monegan, but that the jurisdictional matter should be settled first.<ref>{{cite news|author=Len Tepper, Brian Ross, and Maddy Sauer|url=http://www.abcnews.go.com/print?id=5717877|title=Palin Aide Ducks State Probe: Aide's Lawyer Cancels Deposition, Questions Legislature's Jurisdiction|publisher=ABC News|date=2008-09-03|accessdate=2008-09-04}}</ref> In response to this, Rep. Ramras (R), chair of the House Judiciary Committee, said "Alaskans should be offended, that Frank Bailey is on paid leave and will not do an interview that he already committed to with Mr. Branchflower."<ref>{{cite news
|first=Corey
|last=Allen-Young
|title=Gov. Palin Troopergate: Possible stall in investigation
|work=CBS 11 (KTVA)
|date=2008-09-04
|accessdate=2008-09-07
|url=http://www.ktva.com/ci_10374118
}}</ref>

On September 9, Senior Assistant Attorney General Mike Barnhill wrote to Legislative Council chair Sen. Kim Elton threatening to go to court to confirm that it was legal for the Governor to assign her staff to review personnel files. He said that, if the lawmakers agreed that this interpretation of the law was correct, the Attorney General's office "will drop its objections [to state employees testifying] and the depositions may proceed without subpoenas."<ref>
{{cite news
|title=Palin staff may fight Troopergate subpoenas
|first=Gene
|last=Johnson
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|url=http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/story/523705.html
|date=2008-09-12
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}
</ref> On September 12, Sen. Elton agreed with Barnhill's proposal, writing that "I stipulate in my role as a chair of the Legislative Council and on behalf of the council that your interpretation of the law is correct."<ref>{{cite news
|title=McCain-Palin campaign accused of co-opting Department of Law
|first=Jason
|last=Moore
|work = KTUU/NBC
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/global/story.asp?s=9030139
|date=2008-09-17
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}</ref>

====Issue of subpoenas and response====
On September 12, the Alaska Senate Judiciary Committee issued [[subpoena]]s to thirteen potential witnesses: Todd Palin, Ivy Frye (a Palin assistant), Randy Ruaro (Palin's Deputy Chief of Staff), Frank Bailey (Palin's director of boards and commissions), John Bitney (former legislative director for Palin), Annette Kreitzer (Commissioner of the Department of Administration, or DOA), Dianne Kiesel (former director of the Division of Personnel and Labor Relations in DOA), Nicki Neal (current director of the Division of Personnel and Labor Relations in DOA), Brad Thompson (director of the Division of Risk Management in DOA), Michael Nizich (Palin's Chief of Staff), Kris Perry (manager of Palin's Anchorage office), Janice Mason (Palin’s schedule coordinator), and Murlene Wilkes (owner of a private company that processes worker's compensation claims).<ref name="adn9-5">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.adn.com/monegan/story/517072.html
|title=Palin won't face 'Troopergate' subpoena
|publisher=''Anchorage Daily News''
|date=2008-09-05
}}
</ref><ref name="meetingminutes9-12">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.legis.state.ak.us/pdf/25/M/SJUD2008-09-120915.PDF
|title=Minutes of joint meeting, Senate and House Judiciary Committees
|date=2008-09-12
}}
</ref> The Committee also authorized a subpoena for Bailey's cell-phone records.<ref>
{{cite news
|title=Lawmakers vote to subpoena 13 in Troopergate
|first=Wesley
|last=Loy
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|date=2008-09-13
|accessdate=2008-09-13
|url=http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/story/524697.html
}}
</ref><ref name="quinn">
{{cite news
|title=Subpoenas to be issued for Troopergate probe
|first=Steve
|last=Quinn
|work = Associated Press
|date=2008-09-05
|url=http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5h7VIY5GfDmjy-A5HsGLuHvA0SHtgD930S0OG0
|accessdate=2008-09-05
}}
</ref>

According to Branchflower, Wilkes may have lied to him during an earlier interview, and may have had a financial incentive to cover up being pressured by the Palins to deny Wooten's worker's compensation claim. Branchflower said an employee at Wilkes' company had called a tip line and said "the governor's office wanted this claim denied."<ref name="usatoday9-13">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.usatoday.com/news/politics/election2008/2008-09-13-alaska-probe_N.htm
|title=Alaska probe seeks subpoenas as Palin halts cooperation
|date=2008-09-13
}}
</ref> According to KTUU, "knowingly denying a worker's comp claim for false reasons is a criminal offense."<ref name="ktuu9-19">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/Global/story.asp?S=9043714
|title=French: Investigation continues despite no shows
|first=Jason
|last=Moore
|date=2008-09-19
}}
</ref> Sarah Palin herself was not subpoenaed: Ramras said that it "would be disrespectful" for the committee to subpoena the governor while she was running for Vice President.<ref>{{cite web| last = Roth| first = Zachary | title = Palin Won't Be Subpoenaed on Trooper-Gate | publisher = ''[[Talking Points Memo]]''| date = September 5, 2008| url =http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/2008/09/palin_wont_be_subpoenaed_on_tr.php | accessdate = 2008-09-10}}</ref> The Alaska Senate Judiciary Committee, which voted to issue the subpoenas, is composed of three Republicans and two Democrats. The vote was 3-2.<ref name="cnn9-12">
{{cite news
|url=http://edition.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/12/palin.investigation/index.html
|title=Lawmakers vote to subpoena Palin's husband, aides
|date=September 12, 2008
|publisher=CNN
}}
</ref> The subpoenas were authorized at a joint meeting of the House and Senate Judiciary Committees. The House Judiciary Committee also voted, in an advisory capacity, in favor of authorizing the subpoenas. This vote was 5-0. Those five include three Republicans and two Democrats. Two Republican members of the House Judiciary Committee were not present.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/>

On September 16, saying that the investigation was "tainted" by manipulations from Barack Obama's supporters, a McCain-Palin spokesperson said that Palin would not cooperate with the investigator hired by the legislature. The Obama campaign said that the claim of manipulation was "complete paranoia."<ref name="cnn9-16">{{cite news|publisher=[[CNN]]|title=Palin aide says Obama backers politicizing Alaska investigation|url=http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/16/palin.investigation/index.html|date=September 16, 2008|}}</ref>

On September 16, State Attorney General [[Talis Colberg]], a Palin appointee, notified the Legislature that state employees would disobey the subpoenas issued in the course of the investigation, unless either the full Senate or the legislature as a whole voted to compel their testimony. He stated that the officials were "loyal employees subject to the supervision of the Governor" and cited Governor Palin's decision not to co-operate with the inquiry, her statement that the subpoenas were "of questionable validity," and the pending lawsuits challenging the investigation. He added that the employees were in "an untenable situation."<ref>{{Citation| last = Quinn| first = Steve | title = Alaska AG: State employees won't honor subpoenas| newspaper = [[The Guardian]]| year = 2008| date = September 17, 2008| url = http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/feedarticle/7803852}}</ref><ref>{{cite web
|title=Letter from Talis J. Colberg to Senator Kim Elton
|url=http://www.juneauempire.com/documents/091708/LtrtoSenElton91608.pdf
|date=2008-09-16
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}</ref> The full Alaska legislature is not scheduled to convene until January 2009: it could not meet earlier unless a Special Session is called by Governor Palin.<ref name="forgey"/>

In response to Attorney General Colberg's letter, Sen. Elton accused the administration of breaking an earlier agreement to allow the employees to testify.<ref name="forgey">
{{cite news
|title=Elton criticizes Palin's response to subpoenas
|first=Pat
|last=Forgey
|work=Juneau Empire
|url=http://www.juneauempire.com/stories/091808/sta_333851978.shtml
|date=2008-09-18
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}
</ref><ref name="eltonletter">{{cite web
|title=Letter from Senator Kim Elton to Talis J. Colberg
|url= http://www.juneauempire.com/documents/091808/Colbergresponse091708.pdf
|date=2008-09-17
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}</ref> He cited several public statements by Palin or her staff pledging her cooperation, in addition to what he called the "explicit" offer in the earlier letter of September 9 to allow the testimony, provided that the administration's interpretation of the State Personnel Act was agreed upon.<ref name="eltonletter"/>

Also on September 16, five GOP lawmakers from the Alaskan State Legislature filed a lawsuit in Anchorage Superior Court to end the investigation, claiming it was "unlawful, biased, partial and partisan."<ref>{{cite news|publisher=[[The Huffington Post]]|title=GOP Lawmakers Sue To Stop Palin Trooper Investigation|url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/09/16/gop-lawmakers-sue-to-stop_n_126901.html|date=September 16, 2008|}}</ref>

On September 18, the McCain/Palin campaign announced that Todd Palin would refuse to testify because he does not believe the investigation is legitimate.<ref name="todd">{{cite news
|title=Palin's husband refuses to testify in probe
|first=Matt
|last=Volz
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|url=http://www.adn.com/palin/story/530493.html
|date=2008-09-18
|accessdate=2008-09-18
}}</ref> State senator Bill Wielechowski said that the witnesses could not be punished for disobeying the subpoenas until the full legislature comes into session, which is scheduled to be in January 2009.<ref name="todd"/>

====Allegation that the witness list was manipulated====
As evidence of her claim that the Branchflower investigation was "tainted," McCain spokesperson Stapleton cited the removal of former Palin Chief of Staff Tibbles from the subpoena list compiled by Branchflower. Branchflower had requested a subpoena for Tibbles because Tibbles was refusing to cooperate voluntarily.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/> Stapleton said "French's further political involvement was accidentally revealed when the investigator testified that he had deferred to French on the proper witnesses to subpoena."<ref name="ktuu9-16"/> On October 1, the McCain campaign said "Branchflower and French were recently exposed for colluding on the issuing of subpoenas."<ref name="mccainrelease10-01">{{cite web
|title=McCain Camp Releases New Web Ad: Alaska’s Political Circus
|url=http://www.rushprnews.com/2008/10/01/mccain-camp-releases-new-web-ad-alaskas-political-circus/
|date=2008-10-01
}}</ref> The McCain campaign also said "in a hearing, Branchflower admits conspiring with French regarding the recipients of subpoenas."<ref name="palintruthfiles">{{cite web
|title=McCain "Palin Truth Files" site
|url=http://www.johnmccain.com/palintruthfiles/
}}</ref>

According to House Judiciary Chairman Ramras (R), it was his idea to remove Tibbles from the list: "we did not want to put that onus -- at least this was the point of view I put forward -- I did not want to put that onus on somebody who is now excluded from state service and would not enjoy the same legal protection that has been afforded to those members of the administration."<ref name="ktuu9-16">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/global/story.asp?s=9023109
|title=McCain-Palin campaign continues to blast investigation
|date=2008-09-16
}}
</ref>

In response to charges that the Branchflower investigation is partisan, Ramras stated that the Chairmen and Vice Chairmen of the House and Senate Judiciary Committees comprise three Republicans and one Democrat. All those four voted in favor of authorizing Branchflower's subpoenas. Ramras also mentioned "I have had a McCain sign in my front yard since August 21st, as soon as they hit town in Fairbanks."<ref name="radiointerview9-12">
{{cite url
|url=http://a1135.g.akamai.net/f/1135/18227/1h/cchannel.download.akamai.com/18227/podcast/ANCHORAGE-AK/KENI-AM/Halcro9-12-08.mp3
|title=Jay Ramras radio interview, cited quote at 41:25
|date=2008-09-12
}}
</ref> Responding to further claims of partisanship, Ramras said "the hyperbole from the truth squad [McCain campaign] is a little farfetched … to those of us who have monitored this thing from the front-row seats, it's a misnomer."<ref name="cnn9-24">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/24/palin.investigation/
|title=Trooper probe now 'confidential,' Palin aides say
|date=2008-09-24
|work=CNN
|author= Matt Smith
}}</ref>

====Branchflower's interim status report as of September 12====
Subpoenas were authorized at a joint meeting of the Senate and House Judiciary Committees on September 12. Branchflower was present, and reported on the interim progress of his month-long investigation. As of September 12, Branchflower had identified 33 potential witnesses, and had taken statements from 16 witnesses. He was also working with a large amount of material that had been produced by the Colberg investigation, and turned over to him.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/>

Branchflower said there was enough evidence in the public record to support the claim that Todd Palin was the principal critic of Trooper Wooten. Todd Palin had many contacts with DPS personnel over the last several years and made many comments about how it appeared that DPS was not doing its job because of Wooten; he wanted Wooten fired.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/> Branchflower described Monegan's account of his meeting with Todd Palin in January 2007. Palin said Wooten's suspension was inadequate. In a legal filing in September 2008, Sarah Palin said her family didn't learn until July 2008 that Wooten had been discliplined with a suspension in 2006.<ref name="ethicsdisclosureform">{{cite url
|url=http://www.politico.com/static/PPM103_ethics2222.html
|title=Ethics Disclosure Form
|first=Sarah
|last=Palin
|date=2008-09-01
}}
</ref>

====Status of Branchflower's subpoenas as of September 19====
On September 19, French issued a letter detailing the status of the thirteen witness subpoenas authorized by the Senate Judiciary Committee on September 12.<ref name="frenchletter9-19">
{{cite url
|url=http://community.adn.com/sites/community.adn.com/files/2008.09.19.PDF
|title=French's letter describing status of subpoenas
|first=Hollis
|last=French
|date=2008-09-19
}}
</ref> As of the 19th, six of the subpoenas had been served, to Todd Palin, Ivy Frye, Ruaro, Bailey, Bitney and Wilkes. The former three failed to appear on September 19, as ordered. The latter three complied with the subpoena by providing statements to Branchflower. The cell-phone company also was served and complied by providing Bailey's records.

On September 19, French announced that Branchflower would serve subpoenas on the seven remaining witnesses (Kiesel, Kreitzer, Neal, Thompson, Nizich, Perry, and Mason), with a return date of September 26.

French's letter noted that Attorney General Colberg's office had confirmed twice, in writing, that witnesses would cooperate. Colberg cancelled that cooperation agreement on September 16. French said that various subpoenas would have been served earlier, but Branchflower had been relying on assurances that had been given by the Governor and others that witnesses would be instructed to cooperate.

====Court upholds validity of subpoenas, witnesses state willingness to appear====

On October 2, Superior Court Judge Peter Michalski rejected the contentions of the five Republican state legislators who had sued to block the investigation, and he also rejected Colberg's challenge to the subpoenas. In response, Colberg declined to discuss whether he would advise the subpoenaed state officials to comply with the subpoenas; he stated instead that he would need to consult with them about a possible appeal to the [[Alaska Supreme Court]] before commenting publicly.<ref>{{Citation| last = Cockerham| first = Sean | title = Judge refuses to halt Troopergate probe| newspaper = [[Anchorage Daily News]]| year = 2008| date = October 2, 2008| url = http://www.adn.com/palin/story/543892.html}}</ref>

On October 5, seven of the witnesses agreed that they would testify, leaving only the Palins' own appearance in doubt.<ref>{{citation|url= http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5jOTk11gvqDAgD0cY3i4WjI_2YOxwD93KM4LG0|newspaper=[[associated press]]|date = october 5, 2008|title = 7 Palin aides to testify in abuse-of-power probe|name=Apuzzo, Matt}}</ref>

===State Personnel Board investigation===
On September 1, Palin essentially filed an ethics complaint against herself, asking the state Personnel Board to review the case.<ref>
{{cite url
|url=http://www.politico.com/static/PPM103_ethics2222.html
|title=Ethics Disclosure Form
|date=2008-09-01
}}
</ref> Her lawyer asked the state Legislature to drop its investigation, saying that by state law, the board had jurisdiction over ethics issues.<ref name="ADN-Ethics complaint">{{cite news|first=Lisa|last=Demer|url=http://www.adn.com/politics/story/514163.html|title=Palin seeks review of Monegan firing case: Governor makes ethics complaint against herself to force action|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-09-02|accessdate=2008-09-04}}</ref> Palin also asked that the Board review the matter as an ethics complaint.<ref name="ADN-1Sep08b"/>

The Personnel Board is a three-member panel appointed by the governor. Members serve a six-year term.<ref name="adn9-19">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.mcclatchydc.com/homepage/story/52764.html
|title=Todd Palin rejects subpoena in 'troopergate' probe
|date=2008-09-19
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|author= Wesley Loy
}}</ref> The three people on the current board were first appointed by [[Frank Murkowski]] (R), Palin's gubernatorial predecessor; Palin reappointed one member in 2008.<ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/03/palin.investigation/|title=Palin asks state board to take over trooper probe|date=2008-09-03|publisher=CNN}}</ref> Another member donated $400 to Palin's 2006 campaign for governor.<ref name="cbs9-6">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/09/06/politics/main4422385.shtml
|title=Subpoenas Due In Palin Trooper Probe
|date=2008-09-06
}}
</ref> As governor, Palin has the authority to remove members of the board, for cause.<ref name="wp9-22">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/22/AR2008092202600_pf.html
|title=Palin lawyer meets with investigator in probe
|date=2008-09-22
|work=Associated Press
|author= Matt Voltz
}}
</ref> The investigator hired by the Personnel Board is Tim Petumenos. In 2002, his firm handled the $15 million bond issue for Wasilla's hockey complex, a pet project of then-mayor Palin.<ref>http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/newsreader/story/535638.html</ref>

In response to the request from Palin's attorney, French responded that "We're going to proceed. If they want to proceed, that's perfectly within their right but it doesn't diminish our right to do so."<ref name="ADN-2Sep08" /><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.adn.com/sarah-palin/story/514056.html|title=Palin wants investigation yanked from Legislature|last=Demer|first=Lisa |date=2008-09-02|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''}}</ref>

On September 3, Nicki Neal, director of the state Division of Personnel and Labor Relations, said that the board would meet soon in executive session -- closed to the public -- to begin its work. Palin had asked for the ethics case to be open. Neal said she would check into how that relates to the board meetings.<ref>{{cite news|first=Lisa|last=Demer|url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/515508.html|title=Palin aide bails on talking to Legislature: Witness is key in inquiry into Walt Monegan's firing|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|date=2008-09-04|accessdate=2008-09-04}}</ref> Neal is one of the persons listed as a potential witness in the Branchflower investigation.<ref name="meetingminutes9-12"/>

On September 15, Palin's attorney Van Flein filed arguments with the Personnel Board arguing that there was "no probable cause" to pursue the complaint that Palin earlier filed against herself.<ref name="insubordination">{{cite news
|first = Wesley
|last=Loy
|title=Palin accuses Monegan of insubordination
|work=Anchorage Daily News
|url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/527346.html
|date=2008-09-15
|accessdate=2008-09-16
}}</ref> The filing accused Monegan of "an escalating pattern of insubordination on budget and other key policy issues," including a press conference appearance with Senator French, who is leading the legislature's investigation.<ref name="insubordination"/> Van Flein also argued that, even if Palin had ordered Monegan to fire Wooten, that would not violate Alaska's Ethics Act "because the public generally shares a common interest in public order and safety."<ref name="insubordination"/>

The September 15 filing said that a key matter was a planned trip to Washington DC by Monegan to seek funding for an initiative against sexual assault. The filing said that "the proposed Washington trip proved to be the last straw," and that she had not authorized the trip.<ref name="palinfiling9-15">{{cite url
|url=http://sayanythingblog.s3.amazonaws.com/09-08/palin-response.pdf
|title=Motion for determination of no probable cause
|first=Thomas
|last=Van Flein
|date=2008-09-15
}}
</ref><ref>''Note:'' According to the FBI, "Alaska is the first in the nation, per capita, for rapes, and second for murder of women by men. On April 28, 2008, at a conference on domestic violence, Palin publicly applauded Monegan for his work in this area. She said "I want to publicly thank Walt for having his heart in the right place and his efforts too."
{{cite news
|url=http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/Story?id=5778856
|title=Palin Backstab? Commissioner Praised Then Fired
|first=Brian
|last=Ross
|date=2008-09-11
|publisher=ABC News
}}
</ref> On April 28, 2008, Palin had praised Monegan for his work in this area (sexual assault and domestic violence).<ref name="abcnews9-11">
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/Story?id=5778856
|title=Palin Backstab? Commissioner Praised Then Fired
|first=Brian
|last=Ross
|date=2008-09-11
}}
</ref>

On September 19, ''ABC News'' reported that the governor's staff had authorized Monegan's trip, scheduled for July 22, 2008.<ref name="abcnews9-19"/> ABC posted a travel authorization, signed by Nizich, Palin's Chief of Staff, on June 19, 2008, for the trip.<ref name="travelauthorization">
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.com/images/Blotter/TA.pdf
|title=Travel authorization
|date=2008-06-19
}}
</ref>

In response to inquiries about the travel authorization, the McCain-Palin campaign provided a statement on September 19 from Ruaro, the governor's deputy chief of staff as of September 1, 2008. Ruaro wrote that Monegan asked for -- and received -- approval for the travel without telling Palin's staff his reason for going. '"As a matter of routine, the travel was approved by Mike Nizich ... weeks before the actual purpose was made clear by former Commissioner Monegan,'" Ruaro wrote.<ref name="abcnews9-19">
{{cite news
|url=http://www.abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=5844710
|title=Exclusive: New Doubts Over Palin's Troopergate Claims
|publisher= ''ABC News''
|date=2008-09-19
|first=Justin
|last=Rood
}}</ref> On September 20, the McCain campaign said "Gov. Palin’s chief of staff authorized Monegan to travel to Washington … weeks before Monegan revealed the true purpose of his trip."<ref name="mccainrelease09-20">{{cite web
|title=McCain press release 9/20/08
|url=http://www.johnmccain.com/Images/TRUTH/0920_interestedparties.pdf
}}</ref>

Howver, the September 15 legal filing contained a related e-mail: on June 26, 2008, Randy Ruaro, at that time a special assistant to the Governor, emailed Karen Rehfeld, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, with a copy to Nizich. The email began "Walt and DPS want to make a trip back to DC in the end of July ... to get funding ... for work on sexual assault cases."<ref name="palin9-15">[http://sayanythingblog.s3.amazonaws.com/09-08/palin-response.pdf Motion for Determination of No Cause (pdf)], filed September 15, 2008, Exhibit K, p. 2 of 2 (p. 42 in the pdf document)</ref>

===Police union ethics complaint===

On September 3, the police union filed an ethics complaint with the Alaska Attorney General's office.<ref>
{{cite url
|url=http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/msnbc/sections/tvnews/deep%20background/alaskapoliceunioncomplaint.pdf
|title=Letter from John Cyr to Judy Bockmon containing details of Ethics Complaint against Palin and her office
|date=2008-09-03
|accessdate=2008-09-16
}}
</ref><ref name="baileytranscript"/> The complaint alleged that Palin and her officials had illegally accessed and disclosed information from Wooten's confidential personnel records. It said that the call by Frank Bailey, particularly the allegation that Wooten had lied on his job application, demonstrated knowledge that could only have come from Wooten's private file.<ref name="smith">
{{cite news
|title= Palin aides peeked into trooper's files, union says
|work=CNN
|first=Matt
|last=Smith
|coauthors=Scott Bronstein
|date=2008-09-05
|url=http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/04/palin.investigation/index.html
|accessdate=2008-09-08
}}</ref>
During the February 29, 2008 call, which was recorded, Lt. Dial asked Bailey how he had come across this "extremely confidential" information, and Bailey replied "I'm a little bit reluctant to say. Over in admin is where, you know, we hold workers' comp right in there."<ref name="smith"/>

The McCain/Palin campaign responded to the September 3 ethics complaint by saying that the privacy had been waived as part of the Wooten divorce proceedings, putting the information in the public domain,<ref name="smith"/> and that Bailey had received the information from Todd Palin, not from Wooten's personnel records,<ref>{{cite web|author=Aram Roston and Amna Nawaz|title=Alaska police union files complaint against Palin|url=http://deepbackground.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/09/04/1347737.aspx|date=2008-09-04|accessdate=2008-09-04|publisher=MSNBC}}</ref> following Wooten's release on February 7, 2008 of his entire personnel file ("including all disciplinary action(s)") to his ex-wife's attorneys.<ref name="wootenrelease">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.gov.state.ak.us/pdf/pr_08122_doc1.pdf
|title=Authority To Release Employment Information
|first=Mike
|last=Wooten
|date=2008-02-07
}}
</ref>

===Palin's views regarding the proper venue for the investigation===

Palin has made a number of statements expressing her views on the proper venue for the investigation.

==== Intent to cooperate ====

*On July 18, Palin said "we would never prohibit, or be less than enthusiastic about any kind of investigation."<ref name="ktuu7-18">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/Global/story.asp?S=8701623
|title=Lawmakers seek outside inquiry of Monegan firing
|first=Jason
|last=Moore
|date=2008-07-18
}}
</ref>

*On July 21, Palin said that said she welcomed an investigation. "I've said all along, hold me accountable," Palin told reporters.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/471366.html
|title=Legislature may appoint investigator in firing: Palin under fire
|authors=Sean Cockerham and Wesley Loy
|publisher=''Anchorage Daily News''
|date=July 22nd, 2008
}}</ref>

* On July 24, Palin said "I have absolutely nothing to hide … I'm happy to answer any questions between now and when they [the legislature] do conduct an investigation also. … I'm happy to comply, to cooperate. … No problem with an independent investigation."<ref name="ktuu7-24">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.ktuu.com/global/story.asp?s=8733790
|title=Lawmakers move to investigate Monegan ouster
|first=Mike
|last=Ross
|date=2008-09-11
}}
</ref>

* On July 29, Palin's spokesperson said "the governor has said all along that she will fully cooperate with an investigation and her staff will cooperate as well."<ref name="hiredhelp">
{{cite news
| title=Hired help will probe Monegan dismissal: $100,000: Legislators vote to have independent investigator look into controversial firing
| last=Loy
| first=Wesley
| publisher=''Anchorage Daily News''
| date=July 29, 2008
| url=http://www.adn.com/front/story/478090.html
}} </ref>

*On August 13, an official press release stated "Governor Palin has directed all of her staff to cooperate fully with Branchflower."<ref name="palinrelease8-13">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.gov.state.ak.us/archive.php?id=1407
|title=Governor to Turn Over Findings
|date=2008-08-13
}}
</ref>

* On August 29, Palin's attorney wrote to Branchflower: "Please know that we intend to cooperate with this investigation … I would like to review our calendars to schedule depositions of witnesses."<ref name="vanfleinletter8-29">
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.com/images/Blotter/Van%20Flein%20Letter%208%2029%2008.pdf
|title=Van Flein letter to Branchflower
|date=2008-08-29
}}
</ref>

* On August 30, the McCain campaign said "Governor Palin is an open book on this -- she did nothing wrong and has nothing to hide. … she has been happy to cooperate fully in the inquiry of this matter. … The legislature and Attorney General are both currently reviewing the circumstances of Walt Monegan’s departure … and the Governor is fully cooperating with those inquiries."<ref name="mccainpressrelease">{{cite url
|url=http://krmg.com/blogs/krmg_election_experience_red_white_you/2008/09/palinmccain-trooper-memo.html
|title=Press release
|last=McCain campaign
|date=2008-08-30
}}
</ref>

*On August 30, the ''Washington Times'' reported that Palin knew Branchflower by reputation, and welcomed the investigation: "I know he's a prosecutor, probably a heavy duty prosecutor, and so that kind of puzzles us why we are going down that road when we are very, very open to answering any questions anybody has of me or administrators … But I think this process will bode well for the state of Alaska and our administration, having a review committee of those experts in public safety, in the trooper organization."<ref name="washingtontimes8-30"/>

* On September 4, the Anchorage Daily News noted that Palin had made repeated public statements that she would cooperate, and reported that Palin's attorney had said that hadn't changed.<ref name="adn9-4">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.adn.com/uspolitics/story/515902.html
|title=Palin aide skips deposition in 'troopergate' probe
|first=Lisa
|last=Demer
|date=2008-09-04
}}
</ref>

==== Intent not to cooperate ====

*On September 1, Palin requested that the Personnel Board review the matter.<ref name="palinrelease9-2">
{{cite url
|url=http://ktuu.images.worldnow.com/images/incoming/0901-Ethics2.pdf
|title=Palin calls for review by Personnel Board
|date=2008-09-02
}}
</ref> That same date, her lawyer, hired in late August, asked the state Legislature to drop its investigation, saying that by state law, the Personnel Board had jurisdiction over ethics issues.<ref name="ADN-Ethics complaint"/>

* On September 2, Palin's attorney wrote to Branchflower: "It appears that the [Personnel] Board has jurisdiction over this matter … [therefore you should] suspend your investigation pending the outcome of the Personnel Board investigation."<ref name="vanfleinletter9-2">
{{cite url
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/09/02/19/LettertoBranchflower9-2-08.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|title=Van Flein letter to Branchflower, 9/2
|date=2008-09-02
}}
</ref>

* On September 5, French and Ramras made this joint statement: "This week, seven key witnesses informed Mr. Branchflower through their attorneys that they would not provide depositions. Their depositions, which had been agreed to and scheduled earlier with Mr. Branchflower, were cancelled within the last 72 hours."<ref name="frenchramrasrelease"/>

*On September 13, Palin said "we've said all along that … the personnel board is the appropriate agency or board to inquire."<ref name="gibsoninterview">
{{cite url
|url=http://abcnews.go.com/print?id=5795641
|title=Full Excerpts: Charlie Gibson Interviews GOP Vice Presidential Candidate Sarah Palin
|date=2008-09-13
}}
</ref>

* On September 16, a McCain spokesperson said "the governor is not going to cooperate with that [Branchflower] investigation."<ref name="cnn9-16"/>

==Successors to Monegan==
Palin replaced Monegan with Chuck Kopp, who had been the police chief and, for a time, the acting city manager of [[Kenai, Alaska|Kenai]]. She had previously nominated Charles Kopp to the Alaska Judicial Council in April 2007, to which he was later confirmed and continues to serve<ref>http://www.legis.state.ak.us/pdf/25/M/SJUD2007-04-271339.PDF</ref>. The Alaska Judicial Council recommends judges for selection in the state<ref>http://www.ajc.state.ak.us/</ref>. According to the ''Anchorage Daily News'', Kopp "was a rising star in Alaska's Christian conservative movement."<ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.adn.com/opinion/comment/story/531723.html|name=Boras,Alan|title=Kopp hiring proved Palin's fundamentalist street cred|date=September 20, 2008|publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''}}</ref> In Kenai, Kopp had been previously suspended and investigated for [[sexual harassment]] of an employee. Palin said she believed, when she named him on July 11, that the investigation had cleared him, and that she learned that Kopp had received a letter of reprimand only when Kopp held a press conference on July 22 to discuss that letter.<ref >{{cite news | first=Jason | last=Moore | title=Complainant details Kopp's harassing behavior | date=[[2008-07-21]] | publisher=[[KTUU]] | url =http://www.ktuu.com/global/story.asp?s=8712164 | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref><ref name="koppnevertoldgovernor">{{cite news | first=Jason | last=Moore | title=Palin spokeswoman: Kopp never told governor about reprimand (Updated with comments from lawmakers) | date=[[2008-07-24]] | publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'' | url =http://community.adn.com/adn/node/127679 | accessdate = 2008-08-29}}</ref> Kopp resigned on July 25.<ref>{{cite news | first = Megan |last = Holland| title=Kopp steps down as Public Safety chief |date=July 25, 2009 |accessdate= 2008-08-30 | publisher=''[[Anchorage Daily News]]''|url= http://www.adn.com/news/politics/story/475539.html }}</ref> He received a $10,000 severance payment. Monegan had received no severance payment.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.ktva.com/ci_10195264 |title=Bombshell in commissioner controversy |publisher=KTVA |author=Corey Allen-Young |date=2008-08-14 |accessdate=2008-08-29}}</ref>

Although certain reports indicate that Kopp was appointed on July 11, the actual announcement from Palin's office is dated July 14.<ref name="koppannouncement">
{{cite url
|url=http://community.adn.com/adn/node/127018
|title=Kopp announcement
|first=Sarah
|last=Palin
|date=2008-07-14
}}
</ref> The person who was sexually harassed by Kopp sent an email to Palin on July 14, 2008, very early in the morning before Palin made her announcement.<ref name="victimemail">
{{cite url
|url=http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0724/20080724_084201_KoppFileLetter.pdf
|title=Email from harassment victim
|first=
|last=Name withheld
|date=2008-07-14
}}
</ref> The victim said "my sexual harassment complaint against Chief Kopp was acknowledged [and] validated … by the City of Kenai." In a letter to the victim on October 10, 2005, the City of Kenai had said this: "As a result of our investigation, Chuck Kopp was removed immediately from his supervisory role relating to your position. … The City of Kenai will not tolerate harassment of its employees from anyone, regardless of his or her position."<ref name="kenailetter">
{{cite url
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/07/18/16/071608_kenailetter.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|title=Kenai letter to harassment victim
|first=Cary
|last=Graves
|date=2005-10-20
}}
</ref> Palin later stated that when she appointed Kopp, she was unaware that he had been reprimanded.<ref name="koppnevertoldgovernor"/>

On September 12, 2008 Palin appointed Joseph Masters as the third Public Safety Commissioner in a two-month period. Masters, a former deputy director of the Alaska State Troopers, had been security director for petrochemical operations for a private company. He replaced John Glass, who had served as acting commissioner. The ''[[Anchorage Daily News]]'' reported: "Asked if the governor discussed her vision of the department with him, [Masters] said, 'Gov. Palin didn't give me any guidance or direction or mandates for the department.'"<ref>{{Citation| last = Holland| first = Megan | title = Palin names new head of Public Safety| newspaper = [[Anchorage Daily News]]| year = 2008| date = September 12th, 2008| url = http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/story/524376.html}}</ref>

As of mid-September 2008, the post of director of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board (the alternative job which Palin had offered to Monegan) was unfilled.<ref>
{{cite url
|url=http://www.dps.state.ak.us/ABC/contactus.aspx
|title=Contact Information -- Alcoholic Beverage Control Board
|accessdate = 2008-09-14
}}</ref>

==Areas of possible factual inconsistency==

In a number of instances, certain facts appear to be described in an inconsistent manner, when comparing multiple sources.

===Allegations that Wooten is violent and abusive===

According to the Memorandum of Findings<ref name="wall"/> and the suspension letter,<ref name="suspensionletter"/> there was no finding that Wooten ever committed any act of violence against any person, other than the Taser incident. According to a police statement, McCann told police that Wooten never abused her.<ref name="waldron"/> According to a police statement, the DVPO was dissolved because there was no evidence of violence.<ref name="wall"/><ref name="wall2"/>

According to various statements by Palin et al, Wooten is violent and abusive.<ref name="palinfiling9-15"/> Various statements reference the DVPO as proof that Wooten is violent.<ref name="toddpalin10-08">{{cite web
|title=Todd Palin's Troopergate statement
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/10/08/19/Todd_Palin_s_Subpoena_Responses_10-8-081.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf
|date=2008-10-08
}}</ref><ref name="palinemailtogrimes"/><ref name="wall2"/><ref name="mccainpressrelease"/><ref name="palinrelease9-2"/><ref name="mccainrelease10-10"/> In a sworn statement, Todd Palin accused Wooten of "violent behavior" directed at four family members.<ref name="toddpalin10-08"/> On September 2, 2008 Palin said that Wooten was guilty of "violent behavior … directed against … my sister."<ref name="palinrelease9-2"/> On September 17 McCain-Palin spokesperson Meg Stapleton said Wooten "abused her [Palin's] sister."<ref name="stapletonvideo">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.comcast.net/video/858894364/new_evidence
|title=Foxnews video, Stapleton quote at 2:15
}}
</ref> On October 9 Stapleton said "there are numerous instances of abuse."<ref name="stapletonvideo10-09">
{{cite url
|url=http://community.adn.com/adn/node/132506
|title=ADN video, Stapleton quote at 15:49
}}
</ref> On October 10 the McCain campaign accused Wooten of "violent behavior" directed at four family members in 2005 and early 2006.<ref name="mccainrelease10-10"/>

===Duration and nature of the restraining order===

According to the DVPO document itself, the DVPO was temporary, with a nominal 20-day duration. It was issued presumptively on April 11, 2005, based on allegations made by McCann that day, in her written application.<ref name="toddpalin10-08"/> The DVPO document indicates that a hearing would be held to determine whether or not the temporary order should be extended into a long-term protective order. That hearing was originally scheduled for April 27 but actually took place on May 9. According to a police statement, the DVPO was dissolved at the May 9 hearing because McCann could not present evidence of violence.<ref name="wall"/><ref name="wall2"/>

On September 2, 2008, Palin said "the Anchorage Superior Court [had found] that [Wooten] had engaged in serious, violent misconduct."<ref name="palinrelease9-2"/> According to a sworn statement by Todd Palin,<ref name="toddpalin10-08"/> the DVPO extended into 2006. On September 16, 2008 the McCain campaign said
"he [Wooten] is the subject of a Domestic Violence Protective Order,"<ref name="mccainrelease09-16">{{cite web
|title=McCain press release 9/16/08
|url=http://www.johnmccain.com/Images/TRUTH/0916_interestedparties.pdf
}}</ref> suggesting that the DVPO is still in effect. On October 10, 2008 the McCain campaign said Wooten was the subject of a DVPO "in 2005 and early 2006."<ref name="mccainrelease10-10">{{cite web
|title=McCain press release 10/10/08
|url=http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/10/10/08/FINAL_ANALYSIS_OF_MONEGAN_INQUIRY_10-9-08.source.prod_affiliate.7.doc
}}</ref>

===Threats against other family members===

According to the Memorandum of Findings<ref name="wall"/> and the suspension letter,<ref name="suspensionletter"/> there was no finding that Wooten ever made any threat of violence against any person, other than Heath. The alleged threat against Heath was witnessed by no one outside the family. The suspension letter did not mention that threat. Another alleged threat, to "bring down" Sarah and her family, was witnessed only by McCann, and she stated that she understood it was not a threat of violence, but rather a threat "to make life difficult" for them.<ref name="wall"/>

According to various statements by Palin et al, Wooten has made violent threats against various other members of her family, aside from Heath. For example, on September 15, 2008, Palin said Wooten had made "threats of violence" against McCann and Palin's nephew.<ref name="palinfiling9-15"/>

===Threats subsequent to April 2005===

In September 2008, Palin described Wooten as "a trooper who is making threats against the First Family."<ref name="cnnvideo9-16">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.cnn.com/video/savp/evp/?loc=dom&vid=/video/politics/2008/09/16/kaye.palin.probe.cnn
|title=CNN video, Palin quote at 2:20
|date=2008-09-16
}}
</ref> On September 18 she again mentioned "his threats against the First Family."<ref name="adn9-18">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,425161,00.html
|title=Gov. Palin on 'Hannity & Colmes,' Part 2
|date=2008-09-18
}}
</ref> This seems to indicate that Wooten has made threats subsequent to the time that Palin became governor. However, Palin's September 2008 legal filings<ref name="ethicsdisclosureform"/><ref name="palinfiling9-15"/> do not detail any threats that took place after Palin became governor, or at any time since April 11, 2005, when the divorce was filed. Palin's filing on September 1, 2008<ref name="ethicsdisclosureform"/> said "no one in the Palin family ever filed a formal complaint," subsequent to the complaints the family made in 2005.

===Allegations of misconduct against parties other than Wooten===

According to a statement by police, the DVPO was dissolved because McCann showed no evidence that Wooten was violent.<ref name="wall"/><ref name="wall2"/>

According to Palin, the DVPO was dissolved because Wooten's superiors intervened.<ref name="emails"/> According to Palin, the police investigation was "negligently or deliberately slipshod … investigators seemed more concerned about exonerating Wooten than protecting public safety or the Palin family."<ref name="ethicsdisclosureform"/>

===Confidential status of Wooten's personnel file===

According to the police union ethics complaint, Bailey had improper access to confidential information from Wooten's personnel file.<ref name="baileytranscript"/> Palin responded by stating that Todd Palin had this information because Wooten had signed a release placing his entire personnel file in the public domain.<ref name="smith"/> However, Palin has also claimed that her family was not aware of Wooten's suspension until July 2008.<ref name="ethicsdisclosureform"/> Also, Wooten's release of February 7, 2008<ref name="wootenrelease">
{{cite url
|url=http://www.gov.state.ak.us/pdf/pr_08122_doc1.pdf
|title=Authority To Release Employment Information
|first=Mike
|last=Wooten
|date=2008-02-07
}}
</ref> did not place his file in the public domain. It only released his file to McCann's attorneys in connection with the divorce proceedings.

===Claims about prior discipline===

According to the suspension letter issued by Col. Grimes,<ref name="suspensionletter"/> there had been three disciplinary actions against Wooten: a Warning, a Reprimand, and an Instruction, for such things as "not using turn signals," in the period prior to April 11, 2005, the date when the divorce was filed and a Domestic Violence Protective Order was issued.

According Palin, "Wooten had been disciplined a dozen times before he was the subject of a Domestic Violence Protective Order from Molly McCann."<ref name="palinfiling9-15"/>

== Report ==
{{expand|date=October 2008}}
The state of Alaska investigation concluded on October 10, 2008. After a full day of deliberation, the twelve members of the legislative commission voted unanimously to release the report. The report had 4 main findings:

Findings:

# Governor Sarah Palin abused her power as Governor in that her conduct violated AS 39.52.110(a) of the Ethics Act, which provides "The legislature reaffirms that each public officer holds office as a public trust, and any effort to benefit a personal or financial interest through official action is a violation of that trust."
#I find that, although Walt Monegan's refusal to fire Trooper Michael Wooten was not the sole reason he was fired by Governor Sarah Palin, it was likely a contributing factor to his termination as Commissioner of Public Safety. In spite of that, Governor Palin's firing of Commissioner Monegan was a proper and lawful exercise of her constitutional and statutory authority to hire and fire executive branch department heads.
#Harbor Adjustment Service of Anchorage, and its owner Ms. Murleen Wilkes, handled Trooper Michael Wooten's workers' compensation claim properly and in the normal course of business like any other claim processed by Harbor Adjustment Service and Ms. Wilkes. Further, that he received all the workers' compensation benefits to which he was entitled.
#The Attorney General's office failed to substantially comply with (the investigation's) August 6, 2008 written request to Governor Sarah Palin for information about the case in the form of emails.<ref>http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/10/10/16/Branchflowerreport.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf</ref>

==See also==
* [[Governorship of Sarah Palin]]

==References==
{{reflist|2}}

==External links==
* [http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/docs/kopp-severance-agreement/ Kopp severance agreement]
* [http://media.adn.com/smedia/2008/09/02/19/ethicsdisclosureform9-1-08.source.prod_affiliate.7.pdf "Ethics Disclosure Form"] filed with State Personnel Board by Palin's attorney, September 1st, 2008
* [http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site163/2008/0721/20080721_111415_PalinLetterofRecomend.pdf "Character Reference for Mike Wooten"] written by Mayor Palin on January 1st, 2000
{{Sarah Palin}}

[[Category:Sarah Palin]]
[[Category:Sarah Palin controversies]]
[[Category:McCain-Palin controversies]]
[[Category:American political scandals]]
[[Category:Electroshock weapon controversies]]
[[Category:2008 in the United States]]

[[eo:Maldungo de Walter Monegan]]

Revision as of 04:38, 11 October 2008

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Alaska_Public_Safety_Commissioner_dismissal&oldid=244512064"