| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| 'Openly' Partisan Sources |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| "...although it is regarded as poor taste to discuss personal theories on talk pages" |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| "Appears that" |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| "Appropriate to the subject" |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| "Atlas-type" facts |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| "Common sense" on Wikipedia |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| "consensus changing" tag |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| "directly related" edits/reverts |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| "Entropy" in WP:PSTS over the past few months |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| "I do not think that means what you think it means." |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| "Material serving to advance a position" |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| "Novel Narrative"? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| "OR refers to OR by WP editors"? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| "Original images" section |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| "Synthesis of published material" questions |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| "the most reliable sources" |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| "The sky is blue" -- do I need a source? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| "This should include websites"? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| "Tiny minority" view |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| "to advance a position" |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| "Unsigned articles may be less reliable" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| (DIYD)2. Damned If You Do, Damned If You Don't |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| <nowiki>{{cite I looked at the bloody file}}</nowiki> |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| 135,000 |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| 2nd Person |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| A B S U R D ! |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| A better way to look at accessibility |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| a case in point: synthesis |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| A case study (and improving Wikipedia to make a point) |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| A Criticism of WP:NOR |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| A Different Approach |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| A different explanation in hopes of clarity |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| A handful of edits |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| A line big enough to drive a truck through.... |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| A minor adjustment |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| A netural opinion? |
Unknown |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| A new look at OR in general |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| A person as a secondary source |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| A point of interest |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| a proposal - just the intro |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| A Proposed ammendment to the "No original research" limitation |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| A Proposed Clarification of How NOR Is Employed |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| a question about original research: |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| A question of consensus |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| A related essay |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| A reminder to all |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| A request for advice |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| A separate problem with the synthesis section |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| A slight rewording of the proposal |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| a test case for where NOR intersects with Vanity Guidelines |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| A turning point in national history |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| A whole lotta synthesis goin' on |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Absurd? |
49 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Action figures |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Actual proposed change |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Added some motivation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Addition by Blueboar |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Additional opinions wanted - Angie's List |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Advice |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Ahead, not after |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| All primary v. secondary sources discussion moved |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Altered paragraph |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Altered photos |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Alternative proposals: straw poll. |
62 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| An alternative proposal |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| An article about finding research? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| An attempt to rework this policy |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| An example of officious interference |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| An illustration of the proper vs improper use of a primary source... |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| An important distinction |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| an informal request for comment |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| An inquiry on the synthesis policy |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| An interesting case |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| And God... |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Annotated bibliographies at AfD |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Anonymous insertion at WP:RS |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Another calculator example |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Another debate over the use of PS |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Another proposal: moving PSTS to WP:V? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Another proposal |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Another reminder |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Another test case? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Another topic for discussion |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Another word change |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Appear to advance a position |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Apple Pie |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Application of definitions: synthesis? |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Archive naming |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Archiving |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Are examples original research? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Are immediately verifiable statements OR? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Are interviews primary or secondary sources? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Are journal articles primary and secondary sources? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Are most Wikipedia "Lists of" original research? (fork from âGhost rampâ) |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Are simple observations original research. |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Are some articles exempt from this policy? |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Are we offending someone? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Are we sure we want a special rule for scientific articles? |
58 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Article with a LOT of Synthesis |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| articles signed by experts |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| assertions, theories, opinions, and arguments |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Assistance and voices |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Assumption of bad faith in original research |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Attempt to address the new opposition |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Attempt to bypass WP:V and WP:NOR |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Attempt to destroy the policy |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Attempts to refute a position |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Attention needed of SYNT experts! |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Attention newcomers to this article |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Audio recording |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Authority is not a concept in the no original research policy. |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Autobiographies |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Avoiding Nursery Jargon, Welcoming External Criticism |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Avoiding primary/secondary thing |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Back to basics |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Back to the question of what policy should be |
50 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Bad Policy |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Based on use |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| BBC Example |
Unknown |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Before we unprotect the page |
81 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Bias against sourced research |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Bibliographies and etcographies |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Bludgeon |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Blueboar's re-draft of Speny's approach |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Book Review |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Books and movies |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| broken link |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Burden of showing consensus |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| But OR may be all we have! |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Buy Why?? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| C'mon! O.R. is EVERYWHERE! |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Can a distributor's product manual be used as a source? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Can I use Time as a secondary source? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Can it be made clearer that there are no exceptions? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Can Original research be defined without defining the types of sources? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Can somebody weigh on a case of possible OR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Can someone show me a real example of good primary-source material that could not be used under this policy? |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Can we describe good Wikipedia research practice on another page? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Can we say that two conflicting sources conflict? |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Can we use O.R. to argue for or against a source? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Carrying NPOV foreward into NOR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Case study: Philippe Casado |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Catholicism and Freemasonry |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Catholicism and Freemasonry again |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Census as a primary source |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| Change needed? Also, a question |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Change the name of "original research" to "unsourceable research" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Changed "Expert Editors" back to original |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| Changing policy pages to bolster one's own position in an article edit war |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Chess engine analysis |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Chicago manual of style |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Chinese cash |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Christian Cross Asterism (astronomy) |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| Citation indexes |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Citations |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Cited sources =/= original research-free |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Citing Jimmy Wales |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Citing Oneself |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| clarification of "regardless of whether it's true or not" |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Clarification of "Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position" |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Clarification of policy |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Clarification of policy |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Clarification or Amendment of WP:SYN |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Clarification to Top-of-Page Warning |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Clarifications |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Clarifications needed |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| Clarifying "Primary sources" |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Clear and simple (2) |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Clear and simple |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Clearly tieing PSTS to NOR |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| COGDEN's edit (Two-part test as applied to secondary sources) |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Cogden's revert |
40 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| COGDEN's tag |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Comments on 9/20 (15:48) draft of proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Comments on 9/20 draft (minor update) proposal |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Comments on the alternative proposal |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Common knowledge, but no source |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Common Knowledge |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Compromise on archiving |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Conceptual problem for newbie, concerning acceptable contributions. Related to: Are simple observations original research. |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| conclusion / Proposal: more slack for this guideline |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Conflict between Policies |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Confounding NOR and NPOV |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Confusion over the meaning of original research |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Connection with reliable source and verifiability |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Consensus |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Consensus |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Consensus determination ideas |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Consolidation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| controversy over authority |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Controversy over criticism of Quebec society |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Conversion and WP:SYNTH. |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Copyright issues |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Could someone define "self-published"? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Could someone with a good grasp of NOR, and a good deal of patience and time on their hand please provide a second opinion |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Creation-evolution_controversy article (clarification and guidance sought) |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Creative Crackpottery Citing Legitimate Sources |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Crime Rate Example |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Cutting to the chase |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Data-crunching OR? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Data about planets â is some calculation allowed? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Data Mining |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Dave Carter copied from blp talk |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Deductions |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Defining terms by interpreting quotations |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Definition of "published" â Resolved, we don't need another one, an informal poll |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Definitions |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Derogatory statements, and personal insults |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Descriptive claims |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Descriptive plot summeries and primary sources |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Designed to advance a position |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Detailed example of synthesis |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Dictionary |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Direct quote |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Direct quotes and special definitions |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Discussed and undiscussed edits |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Discussing interpretation of poems, novels, and the like |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Discussing Primary/Secondary sources |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Discussion about image use and WP:NOR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Discussion about NPOV, NOR, Verifiability etc. on Talk:Fedora Core |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Discussion about particular attribution |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Discussion about sources |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Discussion of consensus on policy editing privilege |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Dispute about the policy in a nutshell |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Dispute regarding PSTS |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Dispute regarding publication of original research in article |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Disputes between different parties |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Do I really have to prove that Einstein's general relativity of 1915 isn't a result of my original research? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Do interpretive primary reliable sources need to be verified by a second interpretive reliable source? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Do not agree with this site |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Do not confuse the success of Wikipedia with the success of this policy |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Do we still have any conflicts over this one section? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 10
|
| Does adding statistics count as synthesizing data? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Does anybody have concrete instances of what the PSTS distinction accomplishes? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Does size always equal quality of reputation or relevance of research? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Does the "Original" in "No original research" mean anything anymore? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Does the Pope have white hair? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| double standard |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Draft as of 9/20/07 (15:48) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Draft as of 9/20/07 (minor update) |
Unknown |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Draft explanation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Edit summaries |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Editing comment |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Editors citing themselves |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Editors citing themselves rule change |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Edits in April |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Eliminating Primary Sources |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Email to ask question is original research? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| End-runs around WP:NPOV? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| End run |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Enough |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Equations: Original research and verifiability |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Erroneous use of "synthesis" in summary |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Errors in "reliable sources" |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Eschewing original thought is virtue? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Ethnicity inclusions |
98 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Everyone stop... |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Evidence.... |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Example |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Example link broken |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Example of new synthesis of published material |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Example without PSTS |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Examples |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Examples are original research |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Examples too broad; major change |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Exception for maths |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Excluded or included? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Expert consensus |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Expert editors |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 10
|
| Eyewitness testimony |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Facts and Interpretations |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Facts must be backed by citations |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Facts verifiable by Wikipedia readers |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Failure to Communicate |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Fake images in aviation accident articles |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Feedback Please |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Fiction in Wikipedia |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| First sentence |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Flood of peer-reviewed "facts" |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Focus and awareness |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| For clarity |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| For Leflyman |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Foundation issues??? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Frustrating |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Fullstop's description of a primary source |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Fundamental problems with this policy |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| FYI, there is a request for arbitration and a request for comment regarding PSTS |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Getting back to the other debate... |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Ghost ramp |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Goals |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Good article ? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Google Earth |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Got a question |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Grace period? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Grocery-store analogy |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Grocery-story analogy |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| HDI calculation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Helllllllppppppp |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Help with possible original research |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Help with what constitutes original research |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Here's a fun example |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Here in Italy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Historical Datapoints for WP:NOR |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Hmmm... is this original research? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Honored in the breach . . . |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Hopefully, Final version of this proposed addition |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Houston, we have a trouble |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| How does "no original research" fit with plot summaries? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| How I see the source issues |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| How is the current practice harmful? Or is it? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| How to cite sources |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| How to deal with Wikipedia entries about theories |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| How to determine what is a reputable source |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| How to fix the problem? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| How to promote instruction creep |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| How to use primary sources without original research |
73 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Hypothetical question |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Hypothetical Situation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| I Challenge the Following |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| I don't want to write any more until someone breaks up the last section |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| I just don't get it... |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Identifying the ground floor |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| If PSTS was moved, is this policy weakened? |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| If we remove PSTS from this article, where will (should) they go? |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| If we split PSTS into definitions and usage... |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| If you have a longtanding version that lasts longer than four years, please see a doctor |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| Image:Vineland 55-60.jpg |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| importance-s template |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Important text change that would bring in a new policy on what is original research |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Inappropriate editing |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Inclusion of certain exceptions |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| Infinite verb forms |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Info on translation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Instantiating a mathematical formula |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Interpretation of images |
40 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Interpreting text on an image: OR or not? |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Intro caveat in WP:PSTS |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Inuit |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Inverviewing people |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Is adding perspective WP:OR? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Is anyone else frustrated by endless rumbles over the main page? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Is it original research if..... |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Is it original research if... (redux) |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Is it original research to translate an anonymous webboard posting? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Is juxtaposition of A and B equivalent to OR ? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Is linking to a forum post enough non-original reseachness for a nickname? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Is listing a subset from a published government document original research? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Is merging data tables from diverse sources OR? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Is NOR Synthesis applicable to math and physics? |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Is PSTS too complex? |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Is Quoting from Wayback (web.archive.org) Considered OR? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Is research ever really defined? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Is the article Jennings Rutter Battle original research? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Is the purpose of this rule to promote propaganda? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Is there any room for compromise? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Is this OR? "A number of people have done this" |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Is this OR? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Is this OR? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Is this OR? Translation of ancient manuscript |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| is this original research? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Is this original research? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Is this original reserach/synthesis? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Is using a definition original research? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Issues at hand, part 2: The Revenge (Arbitrary Break) |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Issues at hand |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Issues with this policy |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Jelly bean, interpretation of SYNT, and request for opinions. |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Jewish Bolshevism |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Jimbo's quote |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Jimbo Wales's requested poll nearly done - please see |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Journal articles |
82 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Just a little confused |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Just one thought... |
Unknown |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Just to be clear... |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Just to be clear: definition of primary and secondary sources |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Just to circle around Synthesis section again |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Just wondering |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Kinds of claims first, kinds of sources second? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| law / articles about legal cases |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Legal implications |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Legal implications |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Let's find Waldo |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Let me see if I got this straight... |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Life beyond PSTS -bloat reduction âOther optionsâ |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Life beyond PSTS -bloat reduction |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Limited Access Publications |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Limited cases of original vocabulary |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Link to Original Research page |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Links to primary source, secondary source, and tertiary source |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Lists of People? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Looking Better |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Lost clarification against editing policy |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Making a phone call? |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Making your own sources/citations |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Material close to the subject.. |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Math - where is the line between paraphrasing and synthesizing/interpreting? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Math |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Math calculations |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Mathematics |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Meaning of "Novel" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Meaning of Primary, Secondary & Tertiary Sources |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Measurements from maps |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Minor clarification to WP:PSTS |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| minor proposals |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Minorities/Undue weight: clarification of "regardless of whether it's true or not" - continued |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Minorities |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Miscellaneous |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| Misrepresentations by all 'sides' concerned |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Misuse of Wikipedia Policies |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| More appreciative of the role of experts |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| More reasons for sourcing |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| More to be said about the role of experts. |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Most scientists |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Motivations |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Move PSTS to reduce churn |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Move the WP:PSTS section to the WP:V page ? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Moved from bot discussion page |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Moving PSTS |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Moving the discussion forward |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| My Problem with WP:OR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| my revert |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Need a neutral opinion on NOR |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Need Clarification |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Need guidance on identifying OR in the case of ..... |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Need input on page in this matter |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Need some opinion here |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Needed clause: Lincoln's left foot |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Neutronium: Something odd here |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| New combined merge/prot/community discussion header tag |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| New draft, incorporating comments |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| New edits... So far so good |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| New lead to WP:SYN |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| New synthesis, etc. |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| New theories |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Newspaper accounts |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Newspapers |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| No consensus even among the proponents |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| No necessity to cite (second) |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| No necessity to cite |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| No original reverts? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Non negotiable |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| NOR, discussion pages, and 'Explanation' |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| NOR: Content vs Presentation |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| NOR and articles on TV and cartoon characters |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| NOR is a red herring |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| NOR is useful. The word "primary" is not. |
55 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| NOR limiting the usefulness of WP |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| NOR vs. photos made by Wikipedians |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
NotabilitySignificance is central to OR? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| NOTE: There is a proposal to merge this page into WP:ATT. |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Notice of draft revision |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Novelty in Synthesis |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Now historical |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| NPOV and No original research |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Nutshell |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Nutshell |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Nutshell |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Nutshell |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Nutshell clause |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Nutshell grammar |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Nutshell text spilling onto Wikipedia policies box? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Nutshell wording: continuing |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Objections to copy-edit |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Oh, Please, what about Bible stories? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| OK, how about these questions? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| OK, how about this? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Okay, another question posed |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| On sources, and the classification thereof |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| On talk pages addition |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| On the appropriate uses of primary sources |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| On the Integrity of WP:Policy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| On WikiPseudoConsensus |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Only published primary sources? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Open Source Software vs. Wikipedia |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Opening policy nutshell |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Opinions please: should this change have been reverted? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Option 2b |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| OR/Synthesis dispute |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| OR and translation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| OR Claim: 3 legs'o' WP derivable from usability |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| OR in articles vs OR in talk pages |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| OR interpretation dispute |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| OR vs. deficit of research |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Original calculations |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Original consensus formulation |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Original images - Need an admin to assist |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Original images |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Original images |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Original images and 'artist's impressions' |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Original information exception |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Original pictures |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Original research |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| original research |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Original research and disputes of verifibility |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Original research being allowed? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Original research being allowed in some form |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Original research in external links? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| original research link? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Original research or novel idea |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Original Research question - artist-submitted information |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Original Research vs. Collection of information |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Original Research vs Copyright Violation |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Original research wanted... |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Origins of this policy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Osteopathic medicine |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Other avenues |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Over a year |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Overstretched definition of âoriginal researchâ? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Page rename? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Page unprotected |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Parasite |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Patents and research articles |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| peer reviewed academic articles are primary sources ? |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Peer Reviewed Publications Should Always Treated As Reliable Secondary Sources |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Perhaps a "STFU, this isn't the article itself" tag? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Perhaps something like this |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Permissible synthesis |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Persecution |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Persecution |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Personal interviews that were published |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Personal testimony |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Photo manipulation |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Photograph captions |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Photos which are intended to make a specific point |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Picking patterns out of a timetable: OR? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Plagiarism example |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Please |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Please don't start discussions on other pages without repeated mention on this page! |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Please include link to Swedish Wikipedia |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Please let us know if this is OR... |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Please use talk page before adding content |
54 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Policies regarding translations? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Policy changes by SlimVirgin |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Policy dispute regarding primary sources and OR (requested comment) |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Policy on Original Research |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Pool Forge Covered Bridge and OR |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Popular culture? |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Possible clarification |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Possible guidelines about when synthesis is and isn't OR? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Possible rewording of WP:SYN |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Possible way toward consensus: strengthening the neglected S and T elements of PSTS. |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Posters |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Practical and Structural Problems with the Present Directives on Self-Citation |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| Precedents for AfDs regarding "no new analysis or synthesis" |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Preference for primary sources for quotations? |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Press again |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Press as a reliable source wording needs fixing |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Primary, secondary, and tertiary |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Primary/secondary distinction |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Primary/Secondary Vs Original/Not Original |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Primary and secondary |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Primary and secondary sources |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Primary and secondary sources |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Primary and secondary sources |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Primary information as "research" |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| primary over secondary sources |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Primary source distinction |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Primary sources, notability, and this policy |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Primary sources |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Primary Sources |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Primary sources vs. secondary sources |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Primary v. secondary sources in the scientific literature |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Primary vs. secondary: facts vs. analysis |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Primary vs. secondary |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Primary vs. secondary based on content |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Primary vs. Secondary sources |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Primary Vs Secondary sources |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Priveleged experts |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Problem articles |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Problem on an article |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Proclamation of protest against policy violation on N.O.R. |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Programming Code |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Prohibiting Original Thinking Precludes Quality Work |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Proposal: change Apple Pie example |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Proposal: just change the terms primary-->raw and secondary-->interpretive |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Proposal: Make explicit when sourced lists NOT WP:OR |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Proposal: more slack for this guideline |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Proposal: State that "no original research" has a specific meaning on Wikipedia |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Proposal |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Proposal |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Proposal : Recognized expertise trumps other claims |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Proposal for removing the coats from the coatrack |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Proposal for second section |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Proposal to move forward |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Proposal to shut up |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Proposals for exceptions to the policy |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Proposed addendum |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Proposed addition: "Original research is allowed on Talk pages" |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Proposed Addition to the Policy |
87 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Proposed alternative example of synthesis |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Proposed alternative wording for Citing oneself section |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 10
|
| Proposed amendment |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Proposed definition of Publish |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Proposed Example of Synthesis - Restatement |
74 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Proposed language as of 9/21/07 |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Proposed new section on Primary and secondary sources |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Proposed text addition to the policy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| Proposed wording as of 2007-Sept-22 |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| proposed wording change |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Protect |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| protected? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| protection |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Protection |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| protection |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Protection |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Protection |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Protection of wrong version |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Provide your interpretation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Provide your interpretation |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| PST in religion articles |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| PSTS- autobiographies |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| PSTS Confusion and Disagreements |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| PSTS and conflicting definitions |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| PSTS and source typing |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| PSTS anomalies |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| PSTS autobiographies |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| PSTS proposals |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| PSTS relative to subject |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Publications in peer-reviewed journals |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| Published = Made Public |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| published court decision |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Published Crackpottery and Apologetics |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Published Original Research |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Publishing one's own translations in Wikipedia |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Punctuation correction needed |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Quality vs type |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Query |
96 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Question: Self contradiction in rules?! |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Question |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Question |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Question 2 |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Question |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Question |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Question 3 |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Question |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Question |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Question about an audio sample |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Question about Census data and crime stats |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| question about usability |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Question about using a novel as a source for a statement about the author |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Question about WP:SYN |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Question for Pproctor |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Question on synthesis of Maps |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Question Regarding Self Publishing |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Quick check |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Rant on special definitions |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Re: WP:BLP#Reliable sources |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Real life example |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Reasonable inference |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Reasonable Inference again |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Recap of PSTS issues for those just joining |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Recent changes |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Recent changes |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Recent changes to secondary sources |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Recent edits |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Recent POV-pushing |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Reference desk |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| References/external links name-change proposal |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Refocus |
69 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Refocusing on the source discussion |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Refrencing a T.V |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Regroup |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Reinterpretation of "Directly Related" |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Related policies section |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Relation of PSTS to "... in popular culture" sections |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Reliable Publication or Source |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Reliable Source |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Reliance on primary sources |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Removal of No Original Research policy |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Removal of tag |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Remove citation from talk page? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Remove two words? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Removed Paragraph |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| removing {{tl|historical}} from talk page |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Removing original research |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Reputable publications -> NPOV |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| Request edit |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Request for clarification: self-cite |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Request for Comment - The Matrix Online |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Request for comments on Original research in Historical revisionism article |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Request wording change and clarification |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Requesting Unprotection of the NOR Page |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Research, Rephrasing and Reasoning |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Restoring "source-based research" and "apple pie" paragraphs |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Reversed audio clips |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Reversion of copy-edit |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Revert: please reach consensus before making changes |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Reverts |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Review of Policy |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Revised primary, secondary, and tertiary section |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Revisiting a proposal |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Revisiting use of primary sources in controversial articles |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| reword in order to assume good faith |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| RfC: Interpreting WP:NOR in the context of examples of Mnemonics |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| RfC: Proposal for WP:PSTS |
93 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| RfC for Hyles Anderson College |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| RfC related to WP:SYNTH |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Safe to unprotect? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Scientific articles |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Scientific Data Presentation vs. No Original Research |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Scientific Studies As Reliable Secondary Sources |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Scope of OR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Scriptures |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Second case study: Jacques Derrida |
56 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Secondary sources: bias, fairness, and objectivity |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Secondary sources |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| secondary sources II |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Secondary sources need not be verifiable by non-specialists |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| secondary sources preferred? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Secondary vs. tertiary sources and signing |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Section Titles are Original Research? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Selective citation to advance a position |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Semi-hypothetical query |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
Semi-protection time? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Serve/serves |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Several changes per day - please stop! |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| SF Giants programs |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Shane Ruttle Martinez |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Shifting the PSTS paradigm |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| should we make a proposed change essay page? |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Should WP:ATT be marked as "historical"? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Sidebar? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Signed encyclopedia articles |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Signed Posts |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Silly Question |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Simple question. |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Simplification: removing primary and/or secondary |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| SlimVirgin's "Synthesis" point |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| SlimVirgin's recent edit(s) |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Solecism/Tautology |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Some advice please |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Some concerns with the current NOR article |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Someone else deal with it |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Son Of Suggestion |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| Sorry folks... |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Source-based research |
Unknown |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Source Definitions? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Source typing in controversial articles |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Sources - Disputed section? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Sources |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research
|
| Sources proposal |
64 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| sources question |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Specialist knowledge |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Specialist knowledge |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Specific applications |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Squaring the circle |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Statement of Gerry Ashton's proposed definition |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| statements concluding: "No conclusion can be made" |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Stating omissions |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Stating the obvious is not original research and there needs to be a grace period for hard-to-find references. |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Statistically proveable original research |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Step-by-step |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Still on OR policy |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Straw poll: Should No original research take a stand against primary sources and tertiary sources? |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Straw poll about interpretive primary sources. |
49 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Straw poll to narrow dispute more |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Straw poll to test for consensus to remove edit protection |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Suggested change to opening paragraph |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Suggested clarification: No original research rule applies to the article |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Suggested tweak |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| Suggestion for refocussing of PSTS |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Suggestions for Getting Back on Track |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 11
|
| Summary of concerns on source typing |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Summary of PSTS issues |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Supporting or WP:SYN |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Sure |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| syllogism |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| SYN |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Synopses of film/video/etc |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Synopsyes of novels |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| SYNT. Yes, it's me again. |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Synt check requested |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Synthesis? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| Synthesis |
66 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Synthesis |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Synthesis example |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Synthesis issue |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Synthesis issue at Doctor Fate |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Synthesis of published material -- request for clarification |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Synthesis of published material is not in itself original research |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Synthesis proposal: without the red herring |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Synthesis vs. synthesis advancing a position |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Synthesis yet again |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Systematic removal in spite of extraordinary obviousness |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Tags on PSTS |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Taking the dive (PSTS proposal) |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Talk Pages |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Template |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Template for violations |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 2
|
| Terrorism |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Terryeo does not answer proof challenge |
52 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Tertiary sources |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Tertiary Sources |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Tertiary sources |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Test Case |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| That Was No Revert |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 12
|
| That wasn't reorganization, that was a major rewrite |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| The applicability of WP:OR to user-created illustrations of extinct animals... |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| The disinformation caused by the OR policy |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| The evolution article |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| The famous(?) "OMG WTF, this isn't what I learned" argument |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| The IAL population hydra |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| The interminable ramble |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| The Line? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| The Mess on WP:NOR |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| The problem with: "arguments that appears to advance a position" |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| The problem with "directly related" |
40 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| The problem with "directly related" |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| The problem with Descriptive claims from Primary research |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| The problem with PSTSâInsufficient granularity |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| The true meaning of Original Research |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| The two versions |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| The way the policy is setup is not clear. |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| There is no real substantive difference between stating and advancing a position |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| There should be EXCEPTIONS to this policy |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| These policies aint worth a crap without critique |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| This dispute is disputed. |
55 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| This is not USENET |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| This policy allows WP to be highjacked by sensationalist publishing |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| This policy is non-negotiable |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| This policy must be destroyed |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| This policy should be deleted |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| This rule cannot work, does not work and will never work. |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| This SYN issue might have come up before |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| This whole issue over the "articles should rely on secondary sources" does raise a good point though... |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Tie-in books |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Time chain |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| To the general public |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Toleration of OR maps |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Towards a compromise: A modest proposal |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Transclusion example |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| transcript of a public hearing |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Translating the Policy page |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Translation(s) |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Translation |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 33
|
| Translation into Dutch |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Translations |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Trolling |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 9
|
| truth |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| TV shows |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Two minor points |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Two Questions |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Unclear section |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Unprotected? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Unprotected |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Unprotecting |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Unreliable citation from reliable sources |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Untested theories? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Use by cranks |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| Use My Brain |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Use of (sic) and [] in a quote |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Use of an example to test |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Use of census data |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 7
|
| Use of secondhand |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Usenet as a secondary source |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| User:Tyresias |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Using Google Books search links as surveys |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Using sources |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| Various OR questions. |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Vehement opposition to this policy, and proposed remedy |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Verifiability, not truth?? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Verifiability (V) - clarification needed |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Village pump |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| violating V implies violating NOR? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Warnings added to policy page |
49 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 24
|
| We need some exceptions to the policy |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| What's going on here? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| What's the largest source-related statement for which there is a consensus? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| What's the uproar about? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| What about documentaries |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| What about information where sources cannot be found at all? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| What are people afraid of? |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| What counts as a reputable publication? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 6
|
| What do we agree on? |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| What does "novel" mean? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| What if it's published in a journal first? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| What if we just swaped words? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| What is a "primary source"? |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| What is a Reputable Publisher? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| What is being done to improve the policy of Wikipedia? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| What is Original Research in the UEFA Cup? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| What is reliable? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| What is wrong with OR? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| What means ânot truthâ in Wikipedia policy statement? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| What of describing assertions as non-sensical and other simple logical conclusions? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| What should happen when WP:SYN contradicts WP:NPOV? |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| What to do about serious editors with legitimate OR. |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Whatever happened to Blueboar's proposal? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| When can we unprotect? |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| When is a lack of sources poor sourcing, and when is it OR? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| When is a theory? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Where's the beef? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 29
|
| Where's the consensus? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Where can we put original research? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Where can we put stuff so it won't be lost? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Where do NOR-interested Wikipedians hang out? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Where is the line between synthesis and pointing out the obvious? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Where is the original discussion for the policy in a nutshell? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Where to draw the line? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| Where to put it |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Who is our model verifier? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Why are people upset with this policy? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Why continue these insults, let us engage in proper discussion to reach consensus |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| Why did PSTS drop examples of secondary sources? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Why has this become so complicated? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 22
|
| Why not just recommend source-checking? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 20
|
| Why Peer Review/Secondary Sources Discussed Here |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Why this discussion started |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Why we DO need some sort of a statement on primary sources usage |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| Why you can't change it (crossposted) |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Wiki's OR policy has disturbing side effects |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Wiki |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Wikinews |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Wikinfo suggestion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Wikipedia:Attribution: Merger of Wikipedia:Verifiability and Wikipedia:No original research |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| Wikipedia:Attribution |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 35
|
| Wikipedia:Attribution |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Wikipedia:concensus |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 13
|
| Wikipedia:It's ok to use your brain |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia:Attribution/Poll |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| Wikipedia:No original research#Reliable sources |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 27
|
| Wikipedia:No original research/noticeboard |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/RFC |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Wikipedia:Requests for verification |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Wikipedia articles include material on the basis of verifiability, not truth. |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| Wikipedia being place for peer-reviewing |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 3
|
| Wikipedia doesn't have a factual accuracy policy? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| Wikipedia is a secondary source on many articles; change the policy, delete the articles, or ignore? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| Wikisource is not the place for original research |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 1
|
| Wikiversity |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 14
|
| Wikiversity |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 36
|
| Word Etymologies |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| Working through the backlog |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
| Working towards a consensus wording |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| Would the Arbitration Committee hear this? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 26
|
| Would this be acceptable, re: PSTS |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 31
|
| Would this qualify as OR? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| WP:ARCHIVES |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 5
|
| WP:ATT: Join the discussion at |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| WP:IAR has more reasons to now to be the guiding policy |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| WP:NOR#Disputes over how established a view is |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 4
|
| WP:NOR and free images |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 19
|
| WP:NOR is stupid |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 21
|
| WP:OR and images of non-existant things |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 17
|
| WP:POLICY dispute |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 30
|
| WP:PSTS |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 23
|
| WP:SYNT at Persian Gulf naming dispute ? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 16
|
| WP:SYNTH violation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 28
|
| WP:WITS (II) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| WP:WITS |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 32
|
| Yet another proposal (yes, again) |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 25
|
| Yet Another Unenforceable Policy (YAUP) |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 8
|
| You cannot describe and summarize conflicting POV's, without violating WP:SYN |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 18
|
| YouTube |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 34
|
| YouTube art as primary source |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:No original research/Archive 15
|
