Absolute firm deal

from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
An example of an absolutely firm deal: ordering the bridal bouquet.

An absolute fixed date or Fixtermingeschäft (also improper firm deal called) is a term used in contract law .

term

An absolute fixed date is when it is clear from the circumstances that a performance at a later than the agreed time for the creditors is completely pointless. Simply agreeing a fixed performance time is not enough. Otherwise every contract with a specific performance period would be a firm deal. In addition to determining the time, it is necessary that compliance with the performance time is so essential for the obligee that a late performance can no longer represent fulfillment .

The classic example of such legal transactions is the delivery of the bridal bouquet , which is pointless after the wedding ; or the New Year's fireworks .

Significance of the time of performance

Compliance with the performance time is therefore decisive for the fulfillment of the contract, because, based on the express agreement of the parties or the circumstances resulting from the parties' interests, the debtor can only perform at a specific point in time or within a narrowly limited period. If the parties have not expressly stated in their agreement that the contract should stand or fall with compliance or non-compliance with the delivery time, it must be determined by interpretation whether the parties wanted to attach this importance to the delivery time; any doubt about such an agreement excludes the acceptance of a firm deal.

The absolute firm deal is expressly regulated neither in the BGB nor in the HGB . There is no need to set a deadline for performance ( Section 281 (1) sentence 1, Section 323 (1) BGB); it would be pointless, since the service cannot be made up for (Sections 283, 326 (5) BGB).

With regard to the interests of the parties, caution is advised when accepting an absolutely firm deal, since they are often more interested in the execution of the contract, even if it is delayed, than in its liquidation due to the impossibility of performance. Absolutely fixed deals are therefore extremely rare.

Further examples

  • Order a taxi at a fixed time to catch a train or plane. If the taxi arrives at a time at which the destination can no longer be reached in time under any circumstances, the creditor can obviously no longer do anything with this service of the taxi driver, so that it has become pointless and therefore impossible for him.
  • Performance by an artist at a specific event
  • Delivery of a subscribed daily newspaper

Absolute firm deal in terms and conditions

General terms and conditions , which attach the character of an absolute firm deal to a legal transaction, which is not a firm deal according to the individual contractual agreement, are inappropriate according to § 307 BGB and therefore ineffective.

Legal consequences

Since the delayed performance no longer represents fulfillment, failure to comply with the performance time leads to the impossibility of performance in accordance with Section 275 BGB. This releases the debtor from his obligation to perform by law (Section 275 (1) BGB). The consideration (obligation to pay) does not apply according to Section 326 (1) sentence 1 BGB.

See also

  • Fixed deal (overview of the terms relative fixed deal and absolute fixed deal)

Individual evidence

  1. See BGH NJW 2001, 2878.
  2. ^ Meub, civil law / law of obligations AT. (PDF file; 17 kB)
  3. ↑ Withdrawal and cancellation of the contract - Withdrawal means dissolution of the contract . Austrian Chamber of Commerce (accessed on January 15, 2016).
  4. ^ A b Ernst in Munich Commentary on the BGB, Volume 2, 5th Edition, 2007 Munich, Verlag CH Beck, § 286 RdNr. 39.
  5. Vlg. Hopft in Baumbach / Hopt, Commentary on the HGB, 33rd edition, 2008 Munich, CH Beck, § 376 No. 2.
  6. See Emmerich in Münchner Kommentar zum BGB, Volume 2, 5th Edition, 2007 Munich, Verlag CH Beck, § 275 RdNr. 47.
  7. Emmerich in Munich Commentary on the BGB, Volume 2, 5th edition, 2007 Munich, Verlag CH Beck, § 275 RdNr. 46.
  8. Cf. Nastelski , JuS 1962, 289, 294.
  9. Vlg. Stadler in Jauernig, Commentary on the BGB, 12th edition, 2007 Munich, CH Beck, § 323 RdNr. 12.