Potter grew up in the curling-loving town of Bemidji and joined the sport of curling at the age of five. Her first great successes they celebrated in 1998, when she won the Junior Championship of Minnesota and then at the World Cup took part in the junior and under the leadership of Hope Schmitt finished fifth. Four years later she made her international breakthrough as the skip of her team. Through the US Junior Championship, she and her team also qualified for the 2002 World Championship. Here Potter was able to win the first ever female junior gold medal for the United States. The following year she lost the final against Canada and became vice world champion. In 2005 she led the women's team from the Bemidji Curling Club to the first national championship and the associated qualification for the World Cup and the 2006 Olympic Games in Turin . At the world championship she finished second and only had to admit defeat to the Swedish team in the final. After five losses in the first six encounters, Potter finished eighth at the Winter Olympics.
Titles and awards (selection)
Vice World Champion 2005
Junior World Champion 2002
Vice-Junior World Champion 2003
Participation in the Olympic Games 2006 (8th place)
US champion 2005
US Junior Champion 2002, 2003
Frances Brodie Award 2005
WJCC All-Star, Skip 2005
Curler of the year in the USA in 2005
USA Curling Team of the Year (Bemidji CC): 2002, 2005