Fiddle: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 08:57, 13 April 2007

The term fiddle refers to a violin when used in folk music. It is also a colloquial term for the instrument used by players in all genres, including classical music. Fiddle playing, or fiddling, is a style of music.

Violin vs. fiddle

A violin is sometimes informally called a fiddle, regardless of the kind of music being played with it. The word "violin" is derived from Italian and the word "fiddle" is English. The two words are etymologically related, both ultimately of Germanic origin.^[1]

Historically, the word fiddle also referred to a predecessor of today's violin. Like the violin, it tended to have 4 strings, but came in a variety of shapes and sizes. Another series of instruments which contributed to the development of the modern fiddle was the viol, which was played while held between the legs, and has a fretted fingerboard.

One very slight difference between "fiddles" and ordinary violins may be seen in American (e.g., bluegrass and old-time music) fiddling: in these styles, the top of the bridge may be cut so that it is very slightly less curved. This reduces the range of right-arm motion required for the rapid string-crossings found in some styles, and is said to make it easier to play double stops and shuffles (bariolage), or to make triple stops possible, allowing one to play chords.

Most classical violinists prefer a more rounded curve to the top of the bridge, which allows them to articulate each note more easily and clearly. In practice, most instruments are fitted with a rounded bridge to better accommodate the shape of the fingerboard. (One exception is the 3-string kontra or bracsa, a viola used in Hungarian and Transylvanian folk music fitted with a flat bridge to allow all three strings to be played simultaneously.) In any case, the difference between "round" and "flat" is not great; about a quarter or half a millimeter variation in the height of one or two strings. As a violin's bridge is relatively easy to replace, modifying the bridge does not permanently make a violin into a fiddle.

It is also more common to see an instrument described as a fiddle if it has steel strings rather than gut or synthetic, and fine tuners on all four strings; it is very uncommon to see four fine tuners on instruments played by classical musicians. (Fine tuners are small screw mechanisms attached to the tailpiece, which make small tuning adjustments easier.) As with the bridge, this configuration is easy to change from "violin" to "fiddle", and causes no irreversible changes to the instrument.

In construction, fiddles and violins are exactly the same. Various clichés describe the difference: "When you are buying it, it's a fiddle. When you are selling it, it's a violin," "The violin sings, the fiddle dances," "A fiddle is a violin with attitude," or, in answer to the musical joke, "What's the difference between a violin and a fiddle?", "No one cries when they spill beer on a fiddle." According to Branson proformer, Shoji Tabuchi the difference lies "in how you fiddle around with it." As might be expected from the differences between classical and folk music, violinists tend to be formally trained and fiddlers tend to be informally trained, although crossing over is not uncommon.

Fiddling

In performance, solo fiddling is the norm, though twin fiddling is represented in some North American, Scandinavian, and Irish styles. Violins, on the other hand, are commonly grouped in sections. These contrasting traditions may be vestiges of historical performance settings: large concert halls in which violins were played required more instruments, before electronic amplification, than did more intimate dance halls and houses fiddles were played in. The difference was likely compounded by the different sounds expected of violin music and fiddle music. Historically, the majority of fiddle music was dance music, while violin music had either grown out of dance music or was something else entirely. Violin music came to value a smoothness which fiddling, with its dance-driven clear beat, did not always follow - in situations that required greater volume, a fiddler (as long as they kept the beat) could push their instrument harder than could a violinist. (Different fiddle traditions had different values, as detailed below; these explanations are meant to present the differences between fiddle music and violin music generally.)

Following the folk revivals of the second half of the 20th century, however, it has become common for less formal situations to find large groups of fiddlers playing together -- see for example the Swedish Spelmanslag folk-musician clubs, and the world-wide^[2] phenomenon of Irish sessions.

In the very late 20th century, a few artists have successfully attempted a reconstruction of the Scottish tradition of violin and "big fiddle," or cello. Notable recorded examples include Amelia Kaminski and Christine Hanson's Bonnie Lasses and Alasdair Fraser and Natalie Haas' Fire and Grace.

Bows used in fiddling

Most fiddling styles that use the standard violin also use the standard violin bow, the same as classical players. However, there are a few styles which use other bows. One notable example is the folk music from Hungary and Transylvania used in the táncház tradition. While the violinist uses a standard bow, both the kontra (3-string viola) and bass are played here with short, heavy and crude "folk bows", consisting of a stout stick, usually hand-hewn, with the hank of horsehair attached at the tip and tied around the frog. The player tensions the hair by squeezing it when playing.

Violin bows used by fiddlers are usually made from wood, but bows made from fiberglass and other materials are becoming more common.

Fiddling styles

To a greater extent than classical violin playing, fiddle playing is characterized by a huge variety of ethnic or folk music traditions, each of which has its own distinctive sound, including, but not limited to:

American fiddling, including
- Old Time fiddling
- New England style fiddling, and contra dance fiddling generally
- Cajun fiddling
- Texas style fiddling
- Contest Fiddling
- Bluegrass fiddling
Arabic Music
Balkan Music, Táncház (Hungarian) and Romanian music

Canadian fiddling, including
- Cape Breton fiddling, with a distinct Scottish and Acadian influence
- Québécois fiddling, influenced from the Brittany area of northern France
- Métis fiddling, of central and western Canada, with French influence
- Newfoundland fiddling, with a strong Irish Sliabh Luachra style of playing
- Maritime or Downeast style of fiddling which has many similarities to Cape Breton fiddling
English fiddling
French fiddling (including a rich Breton fiddling tradition)
Irish fiddling including, among others,
- Clare fiddling, from the central west
- Donegal fiddling, from the northwest
- Sligo fiddling, from a bit south of the northwest
Mexican fiddling from the Tierra Caliente region of Mexico
Nordic folk fiddling (including Hardanger fiddling)
Peruvian violin
Scottish fiddling
Slovenian fiddling
South Indian Carnatic fiddling

List of notable recorded fiddle players

For list of All-Ireland Fiddle Champions see here: Fiddle champions

American

Appalachian/Piedmont

Kenny Baker (Bill Monroe's fiddler)
Vernon Derrick (Jimmy Martin's fiddler)
Rayna Gellert
Bruce Greene (collector of Kentucky tunes and styles)
Ed Haley
Tommy Jarrell
Clark Kessinger
Bruce Molsky
Uncle Charlie Osborne
Doc Roberts
John Salyer

Bluegrass

Contra dance (including New England)

Country

Jazz

Mark O'Connor (also bluegrass, Texas)

The South

Clayton McMichen

Texas

Canadian

Cape Breton

Quebec

English

Irish

Clare

Donegal

Sligo

Mexican

Juan Reynoso

Scottish

References

^ Mario Pei, The Story of the English Language (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1967), p. 109.
^ "The Session: Sessions". Retrieved 28 August. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |accessdate= (help); External link in |authorlink= (help); Unknown parameter |accessyear= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)

@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 ==Violin vs. fiddle==
-A violin is sometimes informally called a fiddle, regardless of the kind of music being played with it. The word "violin" is derived from [[Italian language|Italian]] and the word "fiddle" is [[English language|English]]. The two words are [[etymology|etymologically]] related, both ultimately of [[Germanic languages|Germanic]] origin.<ref>Mario Pei, ''The Story of the English Language'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1967), p. 109.</ref>
+A violin is sometimes informally called a fiddle, regardless of the kind of music being played with it. The word "violin" is derived from [[Italian language|Italian]] and the word "fiddle" is [[English language|English]]. The two words are [[etymology|etymologically]] related, both ultimately of [[Germanic languages|Germanic]] origin.<ref>[[Mario Pei]], ''The Story of the English Language'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1967), p. 109.</ref>
 Historically, the word ''fiddle'' also referred to a predecessor of today's violin. Like the violin, it tended to have 4 strings, but came in a variety of shapes and sizes. Another series of instruments which contributed to the development of the modern fiddle was the [[viol]], which was played while held between the legs, and has a fretted fingerboard.