| year
 | 
piece
 | 
Award winners
 | 
Other nominees
 | 
| 1977
 | 
Porgy and Bess
 | 
Sherwin M. Goldman and Houston Grand Opera
 | 
Guys and Dolls - Moe Septee , Victor H. Potamkin , Carmen F. Zollo and Ashton Springer  The Cherry Orchard - Joseph Papp  The Threepenny Opera - Joseph Papp
 | 
| 1978
 | 
Dracula
 | 
Jujamcyn Theaters , Elizabeth I. McCann , John Wulp , Victor Lurie , Nelle Nugent and Max Weitzenhoffer
 | 
Tartuffe - Circle in the Square  Timbuktu - Luther Davis  A Touch of the Poet - Elliot Martin
 | 
| 1980
 | 
Morning's at Seven
 | 
Elizabeth I. McCann , Nelle Nugent, and Ray Larson
 | 
Major Barbara - Circle in the Square  Peter Pan - Zev Bufman  West Side Story - Gladys Rackmil , Kennedy Center , James M. Nederlander and Ruth Mitchell
 | 
| 1981
 | 
The Penzance pirates
 | 
Joseph Papp and New York Shakespeare Festival
 | 
Brigadoon - Zev Bufman and The Shubert Organization  Camelot - Mike Merrick and Don Gregory  The Little Foxes - Zev Bufman , Donald C. Carter and Jon Cultler
 | 
| 1982
 | 
Othello
 | 
Barry Weissler , Fran Weissler and CBS Video Enterprises
 | 
A Taste of Honey - Roundabout Theater Co. , Gene Feist and Michael Fried  Medea - Barry Weissler , Fran Weissler , Kennedy Center , Bunny Austin and Warren Austin  My Fair Lady - Mike Merrick and Don Gregory
 | 
| 1983
 | 
On your toes
 | 
Alfred de Liagre , Roger L. Stevens , John Mauceri , Donald R. Seawell, and Andre Pastoria
 | 
All's well that ends well - Royal Shakespeare Company  A View from the Bridge - Zev Bufman and Sidney Shlenker  The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial - Circle in the Square and Kennedy Center
 | 
| 1984
 | 
Death of a salesman
 | 
Robert Whitehead and Roger L. Stevens
 | 
American Buffalo - Elliot Martin and Arnold Bernhard  Heartbreak House - Circle in the Square  A Moon for the Misbegotten - The Shubert Organization and Emanuel Azenberg
 | 
| 1985
 | 
Joe Egg
 | 
The Shubert Organization , Emanuel Azenberg , Roger Berlind , Ivan Bloch and MTM Enterprises, Inc.
 | 
Cyrano de Bergerac - James M. Nederlander , Elizabeth I. McCann , Nelle Nugent , Cynthia Wood , Dale Duffy and Allan Carr  Much Ado About Nothing - James M. Nederlander , Elizabeth I. McCann , Nelle Nugent , Cynthia Wood , Dale Duffy and Allan Carr  Strange Interlude - Robert Michael Geisler , John Roberdeau , Douglas Urbanski , James M. Nederlander , Duncan C. Weldon , Paul Gregg , Lionel Becker and Jerome Minskoff
 | 
| 1986
 | 
Sweet Charity
 | 
Jerome Minskoff , James M. Nederlander , Arthur Rubin, and Joseph Harris
 | 
Hay Fever - Roger Peters and MBS Co.  The Iceman Cometh - Lewis M. Allen , James M. Nederlander , Stephen Graham and Ben Edwards  Loot - David Merrick Arts Foundation , Charles P. Kopelman and Mark Simon
 | 
| 1987
 | 
All of my sons
 | 
Jay H. Fuchs , Steven Warnick and Charles Patsos
 | 
Extra sheet - Lincoln Center Theater , Gregory Mosher and Bernard Gersten  Nicholas Nickleby - The Shubert Organization , Three Knights, Ltd. and Robert Fox, Ltd.  Pygmalion - The Shubert Organization , Jerome Minskoff and Duncan C. Weldon
 | 
| 1988
 | 
Anything Goes
 | 
Lincoln Center Theater , Gregory Mosher and Bernard Gersten
 | 
Endstation Sehnsucht - Circle in the Square , Theodore Mann and Paul Libin  Cabaret - Barry Weissler and Fran Weissler  Dreamgirls - Marvin A. Krauss and Irving Siders
 | 
| 1989
 | 
Our little town
 | 
Lincoln Center Theater , Gregory Mosher and Bernard Gersten
 | 
Ah, wilderness! - Ken Marsolis , Alexander H. Cohen , The Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts , The Yale Repertory Theater , Richard Norton , Irma Oestreicher and Elizabeth D. White  Ain't Misbehavin ' - The Shubert Organization , Emanuel Azenberg , Dasha Epstein and Roger Berlind  Cafe Crown - LeFrak Entertainment , James M. Nederlander , Francine LeFrak , James L. Nederlander, and Arthur Rubin
 | 
| 1990
 | 
Gypsy
 | 
Barry Weissler , Fran Weissler , Kathy Levin and Barry Brown
 | 
Sweeney Todd - Circle in the Square Theater , Theodore Mann and Paul Libin  The Circle - Elliot Martin , The Shubert Organization and Suntory International Corp.  The Merchant of Venice - Duncan C. Weldon , Jerome Minskoff , Punch Productions and Peter Hall
 | 
| 1991
 | 
Fiddler on the Roof
 | 
Barry Weissler , Fran Weissler and Pace Theatrical Group
 | 
The Miser - Circle in the Square Theater , Theodore Mann and Paul Libin  Peter Pan - James M. Nederlander , Arthur Rubin , Thomas P. McCoy , Keith Stava , PP Investments, Inc. and John. B. Platt
 | 
| 1992
 | 
Guys and Dolls
 | 
Dodger Productions , Roger Berlind , Jujamcyn Theaters / TV Asahi , Kardana Productions, and The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts
 | 
The Most Happy Fella - Goodspeed Opera House , Center Theater Group / Ahmanson Theater , Lincoln Center Theater , The Shubert Organization and Japan Satellite Broadcasting / Stagevision  On Borrowed Time - Circle in the Square Theater , Theodore Mann , Robert Buckley and Paul Libin  The Visit - Roundabout Theater Co. , Todd Haimes and Gene Feist
 | 
| 1993
 | 
Anna Christie
 | 
Roundabout Theater Co. and Todd Haimes
 | 
St. Joan - National Actors Theater , Tony Randall and Duncan C. Weldon  The Price - Roundabout Theater Co. and Todd Haimes  Wilder, Wilder, Wilder - Circle in the Square Theater , Theodore Mann , George Elmer , Paul Libin , Willow Cabin Theater Company , Edward Berkeley , Adam Oliensis and Maria Radman
 |