List of cardinal priests of San Bartolomeo all'Isola
The following cardinals were cardinal priests of San Bartolomeo all'Isola :
- Aegidius de Viterbo OESA (1517)
 - Domenico Giacobazzi (1517-1519)
 - vacant (1519–1533)
 - Jean Le Veneur (1533–1543)
 - Jacques d'Annebaut (1547–1548)
 - Bartolomé de la Cueva de Albuquerque (1551–1555)
 - Fulvio della Cornea Order of Malta (1555–1557)
 - vacant (1557–1562)
 - Antoine Perrenot de Granvelle (1562–1568)
 - Diego Espinosa (1568)
 - Giulio Antonio Santorio (1570–1595)
 - Francesco Maria Tarugi Or. (1596–1602)
 - Filippo Spinelli (1604-1608)
 - Michelangelo Tonti (1608–1621)
 - Gabriel Trejo y Paniagua (1621-1630)
 - Agustín Spínola Basadone (1631–1649)
 - vacant (1649–1654)
 - Ottavio Acquaviva d'Aragona the Younger (1654–1658)
 - vacant (1658–1670)
 - Francesco Nerli senior (1670)
 - Johann Eberhard Graf Neidhardt SJ (1672–1679)
 - vacant (1679–1696)
 - Giovanni Giacomo Cavallerini (1696–1699)
 - Niccolò Radulovich (1700–1702)
 - vacant (1702–1707)
 - Francesco Acquaviva (1707-1709)
 - vacant (1709–1721)
 - Alvaro Cienfuegos SJ (1721–1739)
 - vacant (1739–1782)
 - József Batthyány (1782–1799)
 - vacant (1799–1803)
 - Pietro Francesco Galeffi (1803-1820)
 - Bonaventura Gazola OFM (1824–1832)
 - Engelbert Sterckx (1838–1867)
 - vacant (1867–1874)
 - János Simor (1874-1891)
 - Mario Mocenni (1893-1894)
 - Egidio Mauri OP (1894–1895)
 - Johann Evangelist Haller (1896–1900)
 - Bartolomeo Bacilieri (1901-1923)
 - Enrico Gasparri (1925-1933)
 - Carlo Salotti (1936–1939)
 - Grégoire-Pierre Agagianian (1946–1970)
 - Aníbal Muñoz Duque (1973–1987)
 - Mario Revollo Bravo (1988–1995)
 - Francis Eugene George OMI (1998-2015)
 - Blase Joseph Cupich (since 2016)