Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe

from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
Participating states
Members and partners
  • 57 OSCE participating States
  • 11 partner countries
  • management
    Secretary General SwitzerlandSwitzerland Thomas Greminger
    Chairman AlbaniaAlbania Edi Rama
    OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media FranceFrance Harlem Désir
    founding
    Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE) July 1973
    Helsinki Final Act August 1, 1975
    Charter of Paris November 21, 1990
    renamed the OSCE January 1, 1995
    Others
    Seat AustriaAustria Vienna 1 , Wallnerstraße 6 (Palais Pálffy) Coordinates: 48 ° 12 ′ 36.2 ″  N , 16 ° 21 ′ 53.2 ″  E
    Website www.osce.org

    The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe ( OSCE ; English Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe , OSCE ) is a verstetigte Conference peacekeeping. On January 1, 1995, it emerged from the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE), which was founded on August 1, 1975 with the Helsinki Final Act . The OSCE consists of the following 57 participating States:

    The seat of the General Secretariat and the most important bodies is Vienna with the Hofburg and, since 2007, also the Palais Pálffy on Wallnerstraße (headquarters).

    aims

    The goals of the OSCE are securing peace and post-conflict reconstruction. She sees herself as a stabilizing factor in Europe. As a regional agreement according to Chapter VIII of the Charter of the United Nations , the OSCE is to serve as the first international point of contact in conflicts within its sphere of activity in accordance with the principle of subsidiarity . It is seen as a system of collective security and is therefore in competition with NATO , which is, however, much more militarily oriented. It also works with international organizations on the "OSCE first" principle . Due to the unsuccessful 2010 Summit, the question of future goals for the OSCE remained open.

    The activities of the OSCE are divided into three thematic areas (“dimensions”), which go back to the three baskets of the Helsinki Final Act. These are (a) the political-military dimension, (b) the economic and environmental dimension and (c) the humanitarian (human rights) dimension.

    Committees and organs

    Permanent Council meeting 2005 in Vienna
    The OSCE supported the IFOR mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina , e.g. B. by support points as shown in this picture
    • Acting Chair (forms the Troika together with the previous and next Chair ), supported by the Secretary General
    • Summit of heads of state and government (decision-making; meeting irregularly, most recently in 2010)
    • Council of Ministers (annual meeting)
    • Permanent council (Vienna, at least one weekly meeting) and committees of the three dimensions.
    • Parliamentary Assembly
    • Forum for security cooperation (can take decisions in the military-political area, meetings weekly)
    • OSCE missions and field operations
    • Office on Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR)
    • High Commissioner on National Minorities
    • Representative on Freedom of the Media (RFOM)

    General Secretaries

    The Secretaries General of the OSCE:

    The OSCE Secretary General has the following tasks:

    Politically
    • Acts as the Deputy Chairperson and supports him in all activities aimed at achieving the goals of the OSCE
    • Attends the meetings of the OSCE Troika (previous, current and next Chair)
    • Supports the process of political dialogue and negotiations between participating States
    • Maintains close contacts with all OSCE delegations
    • Establishes, in consultation with the Chair, an early warning system for the Permanent Council in the event of looming tensions or conflicts in the area of ​​the OSCE and, after consulting the Member States concerned, proposes timely and effective measures to resolve them
    • Can submit any topic related to his or her mandate to the decision-making bodies, in consultation with the chairman
    • Takes an active part in the debates of the Permanent Council and Forum for Security Co-operation
    Administrative
    • Is the Administrative Director of the OSCE and Head of the OSCE Secretariat
    • Ensures the implementation of the decisions of the OSCE
    • Submit the program of activities and the overall budget to the Permanent Council
    • Oversees the OSCE's activities in the field and coordinates its operational work
    • Ensures the program coordination between the secretariat, the institutions and the activities in the field as well as within these activities
    • Forms the interface for coordination and advice between the OSCE institutions and regularly holds coordination meetings with their heads in order to achieve synergies and avoid duplication

    Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights

    The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR, the English abbreviation ODIHR ) in Warsaw is the “Main Institution of the Human Dimension” (Basket III) of the OSCE. Originally the Free Elections Office (an international election observation institution) was the human dimension component of the institutional package to be negotiated at the Paris Summit of the CSCE in 1990.

    His first task was to monitor the elections in the former Eastern Bloc countries of Central and Eastern Europe as well as in the Central Asian republics of the former Soviet Union. The Helsinki Document of 1992 further strengthened the ODIHR, and Norway included the concept of democratization and human rights in the title of the institution.

    As a result, the ODIHR organizes an implementation meeting every two years in Warsaw, which monitors compliance with the OSCE obligations under Basket III and in which, in addition to the OSCE participating States, other intergovernmental organizations and non-governmental organizations take part. In addition, it organizes seminars, supports the missions of the OSCE and the development of democratic structures through a variety of other measures, gathers information and makes it available, and publishes instructions. Election observation also makes up a large part of the activities.

    Directors

    Economic and environmental dimension

    The economic and environmental dimension goes back to the Helsinki "second basket" (cooperation in the fields of technology, science, economy and the environment). In the economic and environmental dimension, the organization takes care of the fight against corruption, money laundering, the financing of terrorism, organized crime and Internet crime, among other things. The OSCE also promotes cooperation in the field of the environment, water management, migration issues and energy.

    High Commissioner on National Minorities

    The post of High Commissioner on National Minorities (HCNM) was created at the Helsinki Summit in 1992. The HCNM's office is in The Hague and employs around 10 people.

    This office of silent diplomacy has been shaped since 1992 by the Dutchman Max van der Stoel, who was replaced in 2001 by the Swede Rolf Ekéus . From 2007 to 2013, the former Norwegian Foreign Minister Knut Vollebaek held the office of HCNM . Astrid Thors, a former member of the European Parliament and Finnish Minister for Migration and European Affairs, began her term of office as HCNM on August 20, 2013. The Italian diplomat Lamberto Zannier has been in office since July 19, 2017 .

    The Office is intended to identify and resolve tensions that could endanger peace, stability or good relations between the OSCE participating States and that develop out of ethnic tensions. His mandate allows the High Commissioner on National Minorities (HCNM) to intervene at an early stage, that is, preventive diplomacy.

    The HCNM's mandate is innovative in comparison to the previous instruments for combating conflict, as it leaves the intergovernmental level and thus enables a direct approach in the affected state. The HCNM is used to provide early warning of minority tensions and may be empowered by the High Council to take early action as part of his engagement.

    Commissioner for Freedom of the Media

    Finally, with Decision 193 at the meeting of the Permanent Council on November 5, 1997, the office of the Representative on Freedom of the Media (RFOM), based in Vienna, was established as the youngest of these three independent institutions.

    The establishment of the institution of the OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media goes back to a German initiative. It is based on the recognition of the particular importance of OSCE commitments with regard to freedom of expression and the role of free and pluralistic media. The mandate for the creation of the new institution came from the OSCE Summit, which took place in Lisbon in 1996. The mandate was approved by the Council of Ministers in Copenhagen (December 1997), through which the appointment of MP a. D. Freimut Duve as the first OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media. His successor was the Hungarian Miklós Haraszti from March 2004 to March 2010 (also for the permissible duration of two terms of office) . In June 2017, Harlem Désir from France was appointed OSCE Media Representative.

    The media representative has an early warning function comparable to the OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities. He takes action in the event of restrictions on freedom of the media, which are usually signs of a political development that is prone to conflict. If serious violations of OSCE principles are suspected, the Media Representative has the opportunity to establish direct contact with the participating State and other parties and to assess the issue, as well as to assist the participating State and to help solve the problem.

    OSCE Commissioner for Anti-Semitism

    The office of anti-Semitism representative of the OSCE, the Parliamentary Assembly Special Representative on Anti-Semitism, Racism, and Intolerance ( English Special Representative of the Parliamentary Assembly against anti-Semitism, racism and intolerance ), takes since 2015, the US Senator Benjamin Cardin true. In his role, he raises awareness of the ongoing problem of prejudice and discrimination in the OSCE region, with a focus on anti-Semitism, anti-Muslimism, migrants, and refugee bias and discrimination in the judicial system. Its responsibilities include advising the OSCE PC on the implementation of its agreed strategies and developing new strategies to strengthen and protect vulnerable communities. It endeavors to reduce prejudice and discrimination in the 57 OSCE participating States.

    Other bodies and institutions

    The OSCC, which is responsible for the implementation of the Treaty on Open Skies, is not directly part of the OSCE, but is linked to the organization in Vienna .

    story

    CSCE meeting place: Finlandia Hall

    precursor

    The OSCE was preceded by the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE), which came about on an initiative of the Warsaw Pact. From the 1950s onwards, the Soviet Union had called for such a conference, but the Western powers, especially West Germany, had refused. Bonn feared that such talks could lead to international acceptance of the division of Germany. It was not until the new Ostpolitik of the social-liberal coalition under Federal Chancellor Willy Brandt (SPD) in the early 1970s that the idea of ​​a CSCE in the West was on the agenda. Under Brandt's motto “Change through rapprochement”, the icy mood of the Cold War was relaxed and the CSCE made possible. The first of these multinational conferences took place in Helsinki from 1973 to 1975 . All European countries (with the exception of Albania ), the Soviet Union as well as the USA and Canada took part in the cross-bloc conference .

    The conference was characterized by an exchange deal: for the Eastern Bloc it brought recognition of the limits of the post-war order and a stronger economic exchange with the West. In return, the East made concessions on human rights. In the years that followed, civil rights movements arose in several socialist countries that invoked the Helsinki Final Act and contributed to the collapse of the Eastern Bloc, so that the CSCE made a decisive contribution to the end of the East-West conflict.

    The conference, originally planned as a one-off event, was continued with the CSCE follow-up conferences in Belgrade (1977–1978), Madrid (1980–1983), Vienna (1986–1989) and again Helsinki (1992).

    At the CSCE summit meeting in Budapest on December 5 and 6, 1994, it was decided to institutionalize the CSCE and rename it as the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) with effect from January 1, 1995 .

    Summit meeting

    The following summits took place in the 1990s

    • December 2-3, 1996 in Lisbon
    • November 18-19, 1999 in Istanbul

    After an eleven-year break, the next OSCE summit took place from December 1-2 , 2010 in Astana . The conference was chaired by Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev . Differences in opinion between western and eastern member states regarding the future content and strategic direction of the OSCE led to another fruitless conclusion of the conference. The planned adoption of an action plan to resolve international conflicts and reform the OSCE failed.

    Meeting of the OSCE Council of Ministers

    At the end of the meeting on December 5, 2014 in Basel , there were declarations, but no final declaration. Chairman Didier Burkhalter stated that the security situation in Europe deteriorated in 2014 due to the Ukraine crisis .

    On the 3rd / 4th December 2015 the OSCE Ministerial Council met in Belgrade (Serbia). The OSCE Ministerial Council met in Hamburg from December 8, 2016 to December 9, 2016 . The meeting took place on the grounds of Hamburg Messe . The foreign ministers of the participating states also met on December 8 in the large ballroom of Hamburg's town hall for a joint working lunch. The meeting took place in Hamburg because Germany took over the chairmanship of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe on January 1, 2016, for the second time since 1991.

    Chair and meeting

    The chair changes annually. A foreign minister acts as chairman.

    year Country Chairman Meeting (place) Meeting (date) Remarks
    1991 GermanyGermany Germany Hans-Dietrich Genscher (from June 19)
    1992 CzechoslovakiaCzechoslovakia Czechoslovakia Jiří Dienstbier (until July 2nd); Jozef Moravčík (from July 3rd)
    1993 SwedenSweden Sweden Margaretha af Ugglas
    1994 ItalyItaly Italy Beniamino Andreatta (until May 11th); Antonio Martino (from May 12th)
    1995 HungaryHungary Hungary László Kovács
    1996 SwitzerlandSwitzerland Switzerland Flavio Cotti
    1997 DenmarkDenmark Denmark Niels Helveg Petersen
    1998 PolandPoland Poland Bronislaw Geremek
    1999 NorwayNorway Norway Knut Vollebæk
    2000 AustriaAustria Austria Wolfgang Schüssel (until February 4th); Benita Ferrero-Waldner (from February 5th)
    2001 RomaniaRomania Romania Mircea Geoana
    2002 PortugalPortugal Portugal Jaime Gama (until April 6); Antonio Martins da Cruz (from April 7th)
    2003 NetherlandsNetherlands Netherlands Jaap de Hoop Scheffer (until December 3rd); Bernard Bot (from December 4th)
    2004 BulgariaBulgaria Bulgaria Solomon Passy
    2005 SloveniaSlovenia Slovenia Dimitrij Rupel
    2006 BelgiumBelgium Belgium Karel de Gucht
    2007 SpainSpain Spain Miguel Ángel Moratinos
    2008 FinlandFinland Finland Ilkka Kanerva (until April 4); Alexander Stubb (from April 5)
    2009 GreeceGreece Greece Dora Bakoyannis (until October 5th); Georgios Papandreou junior (from October 6th)
    2010 KazakhstanKazakhstan Kazakhstan Qanat Saudabaev Astana (Nur-Sultan since 2019) 01.12.2010 to 02.12.2010 1st summit meeting after an eleven year break
    2011 LithuaniaLithuania Lithuania Audronius Ažubalis
    2012 IrelandIreland Ireland Eamon Gilmore
    2013 UkraineUkraine Ukraine Leonid Koschara
    2014 SwitzerlandSwitzerland Switzerland Didier Burkhalter Basel 05/12/2014 Declarations, but no final declaration
    2015 SerbiaSerbia Serbia Ivica Dačić Belgrade 03/12/2015 to 04/12/2015
    2016 GermanyGermany Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier Hamburg December 8, 2016 to December 9, 2016
    2017 AustriaAustria Austria Sebastian Kurz (until December 18); Karin Kneissl (from December 18) Vienna 07.12.2017 to 08.12.2017
    2018 ItalyItaly Italy Enzo Moavero Milanesi Milan 06.12.2018 to 07.12.2018
    2019 SlovakiaSlovakia Slovakia Miroslav Lajčák
    2020 AlbaniaAlbania Albania Edi Rama
    2021 SwedenSweden Sweden Ann Linde

    Participating states

  • Helsinki Final Act and Paris Charter signed
  • Helsinki Final Act signed
  • no signature
  • Partner states
  • 11 partner countries
    Country Cooperated since
    AfghanistanAfghanistan Afghanistan 2003
    EgyptEgypt Egypt 1975
    AlgeriaAlgeria Algeria 1975
    AustraliaAustralia Australia 2009
    IsraelIsrael Israel 1975
    JapanJapan Japan 1992
    JordanJordan Jordan 1998
    MoroccoMorocco Morocco 1975
    Korea SouthSouth Korea South Korea 1994
    ThailandThailand Thailand 2000
    TunisiaTunisia Tunisia 1975


    The 57 participating states and the date of accession
    Country accession Helsinki Final Act signed Paris Charter signed
    AlbaniaAlbania Albania June 19, 1991 September 16, 1991 17th September 1991
    AndorraAndorra Andorra April 25, 1996 November 10, 1999 February 17, 1998
    ArmeniaArmenia Armenia January 30, 1992 July 8, 1992 April 17, 1992
    AzerbaijanAzerbaijan Azerbaijan January 30, 1992 July 8, 1992 December 20, 1993
    BelgiumBelgium Belgium June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    Bosnia and HerzegovinaBosnia and Herzegovina Bosnia and Herzegovina April 30, 1992 July 8, 1992  
    BulgariaBulgaria Bulgaria June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    DenmarkDenmark Denmark June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    GermanyGermany Germany June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    EstoniaEstonia Estonia September 10, 1991 October 14, 1992 December 6, 1991
    FinlandFinland Finland June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    FranceFrance France June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    GeorgiaGeorgia Georgia March 24, 1992 July 8, 1992 January 21, 1994
    GreeceGreece Greece June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    Holy SeeHoly See Holy See June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    IrelandIreland Ireland June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    IcelandIceland Iceland June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    ItalyItaly Italy June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    CanadaCanada Canada June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    KazakhstanKazakhstan Kazakhstan January 30, 1992 July 8, 1992 September 23, 1992
    KyrgyzstanKyrgyzstan Kyrgyzstan January 30, 1992 July 8, 1992 June 3, 1994
    CroatiaCroatia Croatia March 24, 1992 July 8, 1992  
    LatviaLatvia Latvia September 10, 1991 October 14, 1991 December 6, 1991
    LiechtensteinLiechtenstein Liechtenstein June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    LithuaniaLithuania Lithuania September 10, 1991 October 14, 1991 December 6, 1991
    LuxembourgLuxembourg Luxembourg June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    MaltaMalta Malta June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    Moldova RepublicRepublic of Moldova Moldova January 30, 1992 February 26, 1992 January 29, 1993
    MonacoMonaco Monaco June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    MongoliaMongolia Mongolia November 21, 2012    
    MontenegroMontenegro Montenegro June 22, 2006 September 1, 2006  
    NetherlandsNetherlands Netherlands June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    North MacedoniaNorth Macedonia North Macedonia October 12, 1995    
    NorwayNorway Norway June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    AustriaAustria Austria June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    PolandPoland Poland June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    PortugalPortugal Portugal June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    RomaniaRomania Romania June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    RussiaRussia Russia from January 30, 1992 as the legal successor to the Soviet UnionSoviet Union 1955Soviet Union  June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    San MarinoSan Marino San Marino June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    SwedenSweden Sweden June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    SwitzerlandSwitzerland Switzerland June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    SerbiaSerbia Serbia since June 3, 2006 as legal successor to Yugoslavia and Serbia and Montenegro (February 4, 2003 to June 3, 2006)Yugoslavia Socialist Federal RepublicYugoslavia  June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    SlovakiaSlovakia Slovakia January 1, 1993    
    SloveniaSlovenia Slovenia March 24, 1992 July 8, 1992 March 8, 1993
    SpainSpain Spain June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    TajikistanTajikistan Tajikistan January 30, 1992 February 26, 1992  
    Czech RepublicCzech Republic Czech Republic January 1, 1993    
    TurkeyTurkey Turkey June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    TurkmenistanTurkmenistan Turkmenistan January 30, 1992 July 8, 1992  
    UkraineUkraine Ukraine January 30, 1992 February 26, 1992 June 16, 1992
    HungaryHungary Hungary June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    UzbekistanUzbekistan Uzbekistan January 30, 1992 February 26, 1992 October 27, 1993
    United KingdomUnited Kingdom United Kingdom June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    United StatesUnited States United States June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990
    BelarusBelarus Belarus January 30, 1992 February 26, 1992 April 8, 1993
    Cyprus RepublicRepublic of Cyprus Cyprus June 25, 1973 August 1, 1975 November 21, 1990

    Legal status

    Despite its name, it is questionable whether the OSCE has the character of an international organization, since Article 22 of the Budapest Declaration explicitly does not provide for filing with the General Secretariat of the United Nations (in accordance with Article 102 of the Charter of the United Nations). The Secretary-General of the United Nations has therefore repeatedly urged the legal nature of the OSCE to be clarified. An international commission of experts has classified the OSCE as an international organization based on its activities; However, the prevailing doctrine and the vast majority of state practice do not treat the OSCE as an international organization.

    literature

    • Kurt P. Tudyka: The OSCE - Concerned for Europe's Security. Cooperation instead of confrontation. Hamburg 2007, ISBN 978-3-939519-03-4 .
    • Kurt P. Tudyka: The OSCE Handbook. 2nd edition, Springer VS, Wiesbaden 2002, 251 pages, ISBN 978-3-322-92221-2

    honors and awards

    Web links

    Commons : Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe  - Collection of pictures, videos and audio files

    Individual evidence

    1. a b Participating States. In: osce.org. Retrieved August 4, 2016 .
    2. Entry on the OSCE. In: rulers.org. Retrieved August 4, 2016.
    3. a b Alexander Sarovic, DER SPIEGEL: Leadership Vacuum in Vienna: The Chaos at the OSCE - DER SPIEGEL - Politics. Retrieved November 5, 2020 .
    4. 02 12 2020 at 08:11 by Stephanie Liechtenstein: Helga Schmid will be the new OSCE Secretary General. December 2, 2020, accessed December 2, 2020 .
    5. Thomas Grüninger. In: OSCE website.
    6. Hans-Jörg Schmedes: Voting in the view of Europe. The OSCE's observation of the 2009 Bundestag elections . In: Journal for Parliamentary Issues, 1/2010, pp. 77–91.
    7. a b Ingibjörg Sólrún Gísladóttir: Director of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights. Accessed July 19, 2019 .
    8. Internship: High Commissioner for National Minorities OSCE - Humanrights.ch. Retrieved December 3, 2020 .
    9. Monitoring crucial for press freedom, says OSCE media freedom representative in final report. In: osce.org. Retrieved August 4, 2016 .
    10. ^ Benjamin Cardin, USA , OSCE PA. Retrieved October 8, 2019.
    11. Cardin reappointed OSCE . Retrieved October 8, 2019.
    12. Federal Agency for Civic Education: 35 Years Helsinki Final Act (accessed April 27, 2014)
    13. OSCE page on the Budapest Summit (English) with links to the documents, accessed on April 28, 2018
    14. ^ OSCE page on the Summit , accessed on April 28, 2018
    15. OSCE page on the Lisbon Summit (English) with links to the document, accessed on April 28, 2018
    16. OSCE page on the Istanbul Summit (English) with links to the documents, accessed on April 28, 2018
    17. OSCE page on the Astana Summit with links to the documents, accessed on April 28, 2018
    18. Christian Neef: Failed OSCE Summit: Heads of State embarrass themselves on the mammoth show. on: Spiegel online. December 3, 2010.
    19. Russia plays deaf , NZZ, December 5, 2014; "The point of view advocated by Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov was refined in that it adopted the vocabulary of the OSCE principles, but gave them a completely different meaning."
    20. ↑ Taking responsibility is good for Switzerland , Der Landbote, December 17, 2014; "From an international perspective, the conclusion is not positive: the security situation in Europe is worse than it was a year ago."
    21. ^ German OSCE Chairmanship 2016. In: diplo.de. Permanent Mission of the Federal Republic of Germany to the OSCE, archived from the original on August 4, 2016 ; accessed on August 4, 2016 .
    22. ^ Partners for Co-operation. In: osce.org. Retrieved August 4, 2016 .
    23. See Herdegen: Völkerrecht. 6th edition. § 45; Ipsen: international law. 5th edition. Section 34, marginal number 16.