Chaos Computer Club
|Chaos Computer Club
|legal form||registered association|
|founding||September 12, 1981 (informal)|
|purpose||Education , information security|
|main emphasis||Education and Information Security|
The Chaos Computer Club ( CCC ) is a German association in which hackers have come together. The association has developed into a leading non-governmental organization (NGO) in all questions of computer security .
The information society - according to the CCC - requires “a new human right to worldwide, unhindered communication ”, which is why the club “advocates freedom of information across borders and deals with the effects of technologies on society and the individual living being”.
Membership is open to anyone who can identify with these goals. The CCC is a registered association under German law with its seat in Hamburg and according to its own information has approx. 7,900 members. It was founded to give hackers a platform and to report on activities. Participation in the CCC is not tied to membership.
Structure and events
The CCC e. V. sees itself as a "galactic community of living beings" and is organized decentrally in regional groups. Smaller groups are called Chaostreffs , while more active and larger groups of experience (experience exchange groups ) call themselves.
Members and interested parties have met annually for the Chaos Communication Congress since 1984 . In addition, the Chaos Communication Camp took place in the summer of 1999 and 2003 on the Paulshof near the small town of Altlandsberg in the countryside. Following the 4-year cycle, it has taken place on the premises of the Aviation Museum Finowfurt since 2007 , and in 2015 it moved to the Mildenberg brickworks park . The international character of the camp has meanwhile been carried over to the congress, so that it follows its subtitle “The European Hacker Party” and English dominates as the conference language. In addition to the many lectures on technical and socio-political topics, there are also workshops, for example on lock picking . The four-day goulash programming night in Karlsruhe is organized by Entropia eV and is the second largest annual event with over 1500 participants. At Easter, the workshop-oriented Easterhegg takes place regularly on a smaller scale . In addition, since the beginning of the decade there have been many small events with up to 200 people that are organized by regional groups and are partly an open gathering of the community, partly offering lectures on a specific topic.
The surveillance-critical demonstrations of freedom instead of fear are supported by the Chaos Computer Club and sometimes accompanied by their own mobile phones.
Publications, radio, podcasts
The CCC publishes the journal Die Datenschleuder , the scientific journal for data travelers . In addition, the Hackerbibel was published in two editions in the 1980s , an extensive compendium and hodgepodge with numerous documents from the hacker scene. From 1989 to 1992 the association published one of the first German-language electronic magazines, Chalisti . The Hackerbibles and all editions of the Datenschleuder up to the year 2000 have been digitized and are available on the Chaos CD. In addition, since the 21st Chaos Communication Congress (2004) a conference proceedings have been written and published.
Chaosradio has been broadcast on the Fritz radio station from Potsdam since 1995 , usually on the last Thursday of the month as part of the “Blue Moon” program. Further radio broadcasts from the CCC are C-RaDaR from Darmstadt , / dev / radio from Ulm , Radio Chaotica from Karlsruhe , Freibyte from Freiburg im Breisgau , Fnordfunk from Mainz , Pentaradio from Dresden , Sibylline news from Essen , Nerds on Air from Vienna and Hackerfunk from Zurich . In Chaos Radio Podcast Network many are podcasts of CCC offered.
The Chaos Computer Club founded the Chaos Computer Club Veranstaltungsgesellschaft mbH in 1999 to carry out the Chaos Communication Camp . Tim Pritlove was its managing director until 2006 . Since then, it has hosted the major CCC events.Constanze Kurz is a volunteer spokesperson for the association .
In 2003, the Wau Holland Foundation was added as a non-profit organization that has been supporting CCC events and projects ever since.
As a kind of "regional branches" there are so-called Erfa circles (experience sharing circle) and chaos get-togethers . The Erfa circles are firmly anchored in the statutes and usually form local associations with club rooms. Erfa circles are currently (as of 2017) in the German cities of Aachen, Bamberg, Berlin, Bremen, Darmstadt, Dresden, Düsseldorf, Erlangen / Nuremberg / Fürth, Essen, Frankfurt am Main, Freiburg, Göttingen, Hamburg, Hanover, Kaiserslautern, Karlsruhe, Kassel, Cologne, Mainz / Wiesbaden, Mannheim, Munich, Paderborn, Stuttgart, Ulm, Würzburg as well as in Salzburg, Vienna ( C3W ) and Zurich ( CCCZH ). Chaostreffs are looser gatherings of members and interested parties without a registered association.
The CCC also often works with other organizations that campaign against censorship , for freedom of information or data protection , such as FITUG and digitalcourage (formerly FoeBuD). He is also a co-signer of the joint declaration of the AK reserve on the draft law on data retention .
The local association D23 of the DARC , also called Chaoswelle, is a community of radio amateurs close to the CCC.
Chaos Computer Club France
The Chaos Computer Club France (CCCF) existed from 1989 to 1993. It was founded and led by Jean-Bernard Condat under the direction of Jean-Luc Delacour, a secret agent of the French intelligence service Direction de la surveillance du territoire . The primary goal was to monitor the French hacker community and gather information about them.
The CCCF published a digital magazine called Chaos Digest (ChaosD) from January 4, 1993 to August 5, 1993 with a total of 73 issues ().
The CCC was founded on September 12, 1981 in West Berlin at the table of Commune I in the editorial offices of the taz . However, the club developed in the following years mainly in Hamburg, as the founding members Wau Holland and Klaus Schleisiek alias Tom Twiddlebit stayed there.
At the beginning of 1984 the first issue of the club magazine Die Datenschleuder was published. In mid-1984, a self-built modem, not approved by the Bundespost , was developed, the data toilet , the instructions for which were printed in the 1985 Hackerbibel .
The CCC gained public notoriety on November 19, 1984 with an action called the “ Btx hack” or “ Haspa hack”. As a result of a data overflow in the Btx system, which the Bundespost had designated as secure, a subscriber received parts of the main memory content of the relevant Series 1 access computer on his terminal. An analysis of the dump revealed that it contained the access ID of a user account of the Hamburger Sparkasse (Haspa) including the password in plain text. A member of the CCC then logged in as this Haspa user and repeatedly called up a chargeable website of the CCC. As a result, almost DM 135,000 of the Hamburger Sparkasse (Haspa) was due in one night in favor of the association's account, which was paid back after the discovery.
This was preceded by a demonstration of a comparable security hole by Wau Holland at the 8th DAFTA , but the problem was not fixed at the post office. After the hack, Haspa board member Benno Schölermann stated that the Post's assurance that Btx was safe was wrong and that the CCC's efficiency was highly respected.
After the Btx hack, the call for an event got louder and louder to devote yourself to known and upcoming hacks. So at the end of December 1984 the first Chaos Communication Congress was organized in the Eidelstedt community center in Hamburg-Eidelstedt .
Legal action brought by Vorwerk Elektrowerke GmbH & Co. KG
In 1985 the club became embroiled in a matter relating to freedom of information - one of the CCC's later focus areas. With reference to freedom of information, various texts on controversial topics accumulated on the club's BTX pages.
An excerpt from Michael Alschibaja Theimuras' dissertation “ Penis injuries during masturbation with vacuum cleaners ” from 1978 could be called up. Since, in particular vacuum cleaner of the type Kobold of Vorwerk led to injuries, was afraid of the traditional business negative headlines and therefore looked damaged by the CCC. He sued the club for DM 500,000 in damages for damage to its reputation and demanded that the Bundespost, as the operator of the BTX system, block the site. Only after the doctoral supervisor of the dissertation and a person concerned had been proven, the company withdrew the lawsuit.
On April 14, 1986 the Chaos Computer Club e. V. was founded and entered in the register of associations at the Hamburg District Court under number 10940. However , the Hamburg tax office did not recognize non-profit status. An article in Datenschleuder 60 sums up the motivation for founding the association: "The investigative proceedings that were in prospect at the time (because of NASA / Span-Hack etc.) should be clearly channeled in order to prevent further criminalization of the hacker scene ( § 129a ) and above all to direct the investigative proceedings to (lawyers) prepared bodies (board of directors). That worked quite well so far. "
The association is the financial backbone of the data thrower and for projects to research new technologies. In addition, its speakers are active as mouthpieces for the hacker scene.
Several mainframe computers, especially those from Digital, were connected to the SPANet (Space Physics Analysis Network) operated by NASA and ESA . Due to a security gap in the VMS operating system , which was fixed in the USA in 1986, but only in Europe in mid-1987, hackers in northern Germany managed to gain access to the systems and several computers in this network. These included machines from NASA, ESA, computers from the French Atomic Energy Commission ( Commissariat à l'énergie atomique ), universities and research institutions. Evidently, however, damage could only be discovered on computers of the "Hacker-Fahrschule" christened CERN , from where other networks could be reached.
The north German hackers turned to the CCC when the situation got too "hot" for them. This in turn contacted the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution in August 1987 , which passed on a list compiled by the club of all "visited" Vaxen to the US American colleagues at the CIA . As a result, there were several house searches by the BKA in cooperation with the French public prosecutor's office in September 1987 on the basis of criminal complaints from CERN in Switzerland and from Philips France . The allegation was made that the computers of the defense company Thomson , now part of Thales , had been cracked in Grenoble, the databases of the Lafarge cement factory were deleted and that construction plans for a chip were possibly spied on at Philips .
It may have turned out to be happy that CCC press spokesman Steffen Wernéry met a nearby TV team of the station Sat.1 during the house search . This made the house search part of the live reporting on the station's evening news.
On March 14, 1988, Wernéry traveled to SECURICOM 88, the 6th International Congress on Data Protection and Data Security, in Paris. Upon arrival at the airport, he was arrested on a criminal complaint from Philips France and held for questioning. He was released from prison on May 20, 1988 and was able to return to Germany.
The KGB hack emerged from the NASA hack , or rather both took place in parallel and the same people were involved to a small extent. In summary, data spotted from western computers was sold to the east. The main person involved, Karl Koch , was found burned in June 1989 after several therapies to recover from his drug addiction and according to statements made to the Office for the Protection of the Constitution.
As a result of the KGB hack and the investigative work carried out by the Office for the Protection of the Constitution, the distrust among its own members grew, especially in the Hamburg Club. The next few years were marked by the fact that hardly any major campaigns were undertaken. Regardless of this, the annual Chaos Communication Congress continued to be held regularly , Die Datenschleuder also appeared mostly four times a year, and at CEBIT they met annually on Chaos Tuesday to “siege” the post office, and later Telekom.
Reunion among hackers
The CCC used the political turnaround in Germany after the fall of the Berlin Wall to establish links with what was then the GDR . Although the East had caught up in computer technology in the late 1980s (which was mainly due to replicas of Western computers), the access and procurement of Western technology through the CoCom list was either prohibited or prohibitively expensive.
As early as February 1990, a “Hacker Reunification” under the name KoKon (“Communication Congress ”; the reference to CoCom was definitely intended) was organized in the House of Young Talents in East Berlin. The two day event was organized by the Computer Club im HdjT together with the Chaos Computer Club . As a result, a new CCC Berlin was founded, which was able to get hold of a club room in Berlin-Mitte, between Friedrichstrasse and the Reichstag, in the turmoil of reunification. In addition, it helped to set up the first data communication network in the former GDR.
Decentralization of the club
Due to various differences of opinion, especially with the home club in Hamburg, more and more regional groups of the CCC developed in the early 1990s, but they often could not be brought to work with Hamburg. In addition to the new establishment in Berlin , there was a CCC in Oldenburg , in Lübeck (which temporarily coordinated the publication of the data slinger), and a group in Ulm . In Bielefeld in 1987 was initiated by the artist Rena tangent and padeluun of the CCC related, but focused on other priorities club Digitalcourage (formerly FoeBuD), which now houses the Big Brother Awards aligning and cooperating in areas of data protection and monitoring with the CCC.
Decentralization was never perceived as problematic, as the hacker ethic emphasizes the promotion of decentralization as an important goal. Even the statutes of the CCC e. V. envisaged the establishment of independent exchange of experience circles (Erfa circles). Only "rivalry fights" that still occur today, such as between Hamburg and Berlin, influenced productivity and led to some comrades-in-arms completely turning their backs on the CCC.
At the time of the beginning Internet boom, the business with technically ill-advised people was particularly good. People like Sönke Ungerbühler jumped on this train. As an alleged member of the CCC, he alleged to members of the board of directors of banks and commercial enterprises that he had stumbled upon sensitive information through hacking, which the press found food. In return for payment of several thousand DM, however, he would remain silent and hand over the material that had been discovered. The meetings were mostly arranged in London , Cambridge or Brussels , where Ungerbühler then handed over a set of blank diskettes . These fraud cases were rarely reported for fear of damage to their reputation. So Ungerbühler was up to mischief in the name of the CCC for a long time without the association knowing about it. Ungerbühler was able to flee to London from the first detention, which was initiated by a cautious journalist. There were further meetings there, but a sporting goods manufacturer was able to persuade him to hand it over in Germany, where he was overpowered by the police. After his arrest, Ungerbühler reported that some of the unsettled executives had forced the hush money on him. In addition, Ungerbühler said he had no knowledge of computers.
During this time, Kim Schmitz alias Kimble, who posed as a security advisor, was often to be found in the CCC environment . He participated in the newsgroup de.org.ccc on Usenet and was thus often associated with the CCC. After being convicted of fraud, he was banned from attending CCC events, which continues to this day.
At the end of 1997, the COMP128 algorithm became known, which was used to encrypt the so-called identification code on GSM cards - in Germany only from Mannesmann Mobilfunk . This made it technically possible to clone a GSM card, which the CCC proved in spring 1998.
With cloned cards, not only can calls be made at the expense of the original participant, but calls can also be made with their identity. A PIN that has been entered once does not have to be entered again. GSM card dealers in particular were therefore suspected of being able to exploit the vulnerability that had been discovered; because they had undisturbed access to cards and the corresponding PINs, since the letters used at the time could easily be opened without being destroyed and later closed again.
The problem could only be solved by changing the encryption method and replacing the card. However, according to the world market leader in SIM cards, Schlumberger , even in 2002 around 30% of the cards in circulation were still equipped with the vulnerable COMP128 algorithm.
Camp and regional events
At Easter 2001 the CCC returned to the Eidelstedt community center with the first Easter hay . In 2002 the annual goulash programming night (GPN) of the Karlsruhe Erfa-Kreis and the Intergalactic Club-Mate Party (ICMP) of the Erlanger Erfa-Kreis were added, a small hacker camp that takes place every two years in Münchsteinach near Erlangen. Since 2004 the Erfa-Kreis Dresden has organized the two-day information event data traces every year . The Chaos Computer Club Vienna has been organizing the PrivacyWeek since 2016 .
In 2001 the club celebrated its 20th anniversary with the interactive light installation Blinkenlights at the teacher's house on Alexanderplatz in Berlin. In October 2002, the follow-up project Blinkenlights Arcade was created on the facade of the new Bibliothèque nationale de France in Paris with 3,370 m², the largest display of all time. Another sequel was implemented in Toronto in 2008 : Blinkenlights Stereoscope .
Internet censorship in North Rhine-Westphalia
In the fall of 2001 showed district government Dusseldorf with their provincial government Juergen Buessow at the head of efforts, relying on the Media Services Agreement "unwanted" at least in North Rhine-Westphalia to block content on the Internet . One of the actions of the CCC in April 2002 was the first street demonstration it organized in its history. Around 400 participants marched through Düsseldorf's old town with a rally in front of the castle tower and a final rally during a direct conversation with Jürgen Büssow in front of the district government building. He was given a red network map and a printout of the list of signatures against network censorship drawn up by the ODEM initiative .
On July 26, 2004, the freelance IT entrepreneur Dirk Heringhaus published a report in Datenschleuder about security holes in Deutsche Telekom's OBSOC order processing system . Heringhaus called this action a T-Hack . It was about access to modified URLs , which enabled access to protected data in the OBSOC database. The problem could only be resolved after the initial reluctance of Deutsche Telekom. The user groups affected included the Federal Intelligence Service and the GSG 9 .
Members of the CCC and the Dutch foundation "Wij vertrouwen stemcomputers niet" ( "We trust voting computers do not") demonstrated in December 2006, how easily a voting machine company Nedap can manipulate. The effects of the hack included increased security measures in several elections in Germany, the city of Cottbus and other small communities not buying voting computers, and the withdrawal of approval for voting computers from SDU and Nedap in the Netherlands. Because of the hack, an election review complaint was filed with the Federal Constitutional Court in Germany in early 2007 . To this end, the CCC, in cooperation with the foundation “Wij vertrouwen stemcomputers niet”, carried out an investigation that was published in May 2007 following a request from the court. The investigation summarizes the deficiencies already discovered, describes new attack scenarios and advises against the use of Nedap voting computers. With the ruling of March 3, 2009, the Federal Constitutional Court declared the use of voting computers in the 2005 Bundestag elections to be unconstitutional.
On January 23, 2008, the State Court of Hesse rejected the CCC's application for an interim order and allowed the voting computers for the Hessian state elections. After the state elections in Hesse on January 27, 2008, the CCC appealed against the election to the State Court of Hesse. Due to early elections, the matter was no longer decided. From the state elections on January 18, 2009, the Hessian Ministry of the Interior no longer issued a permit for the use of voting computers.
At the end of March 2008, the CCC published an alleged fingerprint of Interior Minister Wolfgang Schäuble in its membership magazine . This was done in protest against the planned expansion of the use of biometric data, e.g. B. in the so-called E-Pass . The CCC wanted to make it clear how easily one's own fingerprint can be "stolen" and used by other people. In the present case, the fingerprints were taken from a glass of water that Wolfgang Schäuble is said to have drunk from during a panel discussion. Schäuble commented on the report: "My fingerprint is not a secret, anyone can have it".
Chaos goes to school
Chaos macht Schule is an initiative of several experience groups of the CCC that has existed since 2007 and that work together with various educational institutions. The aim of this initiative is to strengthen pupils, parents and teachers in the areas of media skills and understanding of technology.
The data letter is a request of the Chaos Computer Club to improve data protection. The concept sparked discussions in politics, especially in early 2010.
At the beginning of October 2011, the Chaos Computer Club published a technical analysis of an assumed version of state spy software ; one of the variants examined was used in an investigation in Bavaria. In its analysis, the CCC concluded that the constitutionally required powers had been exceeded in many ways. So be it z. For example, contrary to previous assurances, it is possible to change data on the infected system or to use connected devices (microphone, camera) for a “ major eavesdropping ”. On October 10, the responsible Bavarian Minister of the Interior, Joachim Herrmann , confirmed that the software came from Bavaria and was used there by the State Criminal Police Office . However, this action could have criminal consequences. "Overall, it does not appear to be ruled out that the publication of the source code of a so-called state trojan is viewed as an act of obstruction of punishment in accordance with Section 258 of the Criminal Code."
PC election hack
On November 7, 2017, the Chaos Computer Club published a technical analysis of the PC-Wahl 10 software used in various elections. The analysis revealed several serious security flaws. The update mechanism, the security of the update server and the vulnerability of the export of the election results were criticized.
Security gap in the health network and in hotel locks
Spokespersons and better known members of the CCC
Well-known honorary members of the Chaos Computer Club are:
- Peter Glaser
- Wau Holland †
- Günther Leue †
- Ralf Prehn
- Sven Gohdes
- Marc-André Janizewski
- Markus Ossevorth
- Hartmut Schröder
- Rena Tangens
- Horst Völz
- Steffen Wernéry
- John Young
- Michael Gerdes (better known as " Papillon Butterfrog ")
- Werner Pieper
- Konrad Zuse † (according to the resolution of the general meeting in 1995, he was no longer informed during his lifetime)
- Chelsea Manning
- Edward Snowden
Three logos / symbols can be found in and around the CCC:
- The "chaos knot" or "data knot" as the official logo of the CCC e. V., designed by Wau Holland ; it is a mirror image of the logo of the Bundespost- Kabel-TV with an extended and knotted cable outlet (see picture above).
- The “plague squirrel” or the “data pirate” as the community's logo; Originally designed by Reinhard Schrutzki in 1990 for the FoeBuD , it is an old Bundespost logo that has mutated into a skull (still with telecommunication flashes).
- The “Fairydust” rocket as the logo of CCC events; The bulbous and tripod rocket was already used as the logo for the 1st Chaos Communication Camp 1999, but was only given its name for the 2nd Camp 2003 and is now, as a seven-meter-tall and accessible replica, at the Chaos Communication Congress and other events.
- Chaos Computer Club (Ed.): Die Hackerbibel (in two parts) Grüner Zweig, 1985, ISBN 3-922708-98-6 & ISBN 3-925817-24-7 .
- Daniel Kulla : The phrase checker. Scenes from the life of Wau Holland, co-founder of the Chaos Computer Club . Löhrbach 2003, ISBN 978-3-922708-25-4 .
- Wau Holland - The Death of a Hacker (Online Article)
- Jürgen Wieckmann, Chaos Computer Club: The Chaos Computer Book. Hacking made in Germany. Wunderlich, Reinbek 1989, ISBN 978-3-8052-0474-3 .
- Thomas Ammann among others: Hacker for Moscow. German computer spies in the service of the KGB. Wunderlich, Reinbek 1989, ISBN 978-3-8052-0490-3 .
- CCC website
- SPIEGEL Online Netzwelt: All articles on the Computer Chaos Club topic
- TAZ column on the membership statistics of the CCC (2013)
- Podcast with the topic “CCC and the public” from September 7, 2010
- Podcast: Peter Glaser reports on the founding years of the CCC on September 1, 2006
- "The hacker Wau Holland or the fight for the net": Deutschlandfunk , February 1, 2013. 43:32 minutes by Walter von Rossum , on YouTube , text on the broadcast
- Martin Kaul: The One and Only In: www.taz.de, December 12, 2017: “The 34th Chaos Communication Congress has started in Leipzig. What once started as a "Friek" show is now the most important society congress of the present "
- ARD "Panorama" from September 15, 1987: Report on the so-called "NASA hack" (with CCC members Steffen Wernéry and Wau Holland ); Youtube
- September 12, 1981: Founding of the Chaos Computer Club . In: Deutsche Welle calendar sheet. Retrieved January 1, 2010
- Presentation of the CCC on its homepage. Retrieved December 28, 2016 .
- Board of the CCC on its homepage. Retrieved December 28, 2016 .
- Holger Klein: The decentralized annual review of the CCC. at 16 minutes 30 seconds. Retrieved January 3, 2020 .
- Preamble to the statutes of the CCC .
- faq , accessed December 28, 2016
- 19th Goulash Programming Night: Chaos in the atrium. (PDF) In: Center for Art and Media. Entropia eV - Chaos Computer Club Karlsruhe, ZKM | Karlsruhe and HfG Karlsruhe, May 23, 2019, accessed on June 3, 2019 .
- chaosradio.ccc.de ; accessed on December 28, 2016.
- Sibylline News The podcast of the CCC Essen. Retrieved on July 20, 2019 (German).
- commercial register dated June 21, 2006 by the Charlottenburg District Court (Berlin).
- Head of the week: Constanze Kurz ( memento from February 23, 2015 in the Internet Archive ) in the Süddeutsche Zeitung , accessed on February 11, 2010.
- CCC: Erfa circles. Retrieved January 11, 2017 .
- Chaos Wave website .
- (English) Phrack No. 64, "A personal view of the french underground (1992-2007)" , 2007: "A good example of this was the fake hacking meeting created in the middle 1990 'so called the CCCF (Chaos Computer Club France) where a lot of hackers got busted under the active participation of a renegade hacker so called Jean-Bernard Condat. "
- ZDF heutejournal from November 15, 1984: Wau Holland on the Dafta - The CCC in the ZDF “Heute Journal” on the Btx hack, 1984 .
- http://brennessel.blogsport.de/images/DOKTORARBEIT_Penisverletzungen_bei_Masturbation_mit_Staubsaugern.pdf .
- Search query in the common register portal of the countries . handelsregister.de - operator Ministry of Justice NRW. Retrieved December 17, 2010.
- Data slingshot . No. 60 , September 1997, p. 26 , col. 1 ( ccc.de [PDF; accessed December 28, 2016]).
- Article in Spiegel 12/1988 , accessed on February 26, 2012.
- Usenet posting by Wau Holland ,  , January 6, 1997, <6ONvrucoeMB@wau6458.other.thur.de>.
- How to forge SIM cards . In: heise online, May 7, 2002. Accessed January 1, 2010.
- data tracks
- PrivacyWeek | October 22-28, 2018 | Folklore Museum Vienna. Accessed January 6, 2019 (German).
- https://chaosradio.ccc.de/media/dossier/2004-07-29-ard_nachtmagazin-t_mart_hack.mp4 .
- The Nedap Hack ( Memento from December 13, 2018 in the Internet Archive ).
- Demonstration of the manipulability of Nedap voting computers .
- Cottbus says goodbye to voting computers heise.de, January 29, 2007
- SDU voting computer excluded from Dutch parliamentary elections heise.de, October 30, 2006.
- Description and evaluation of the tests on NEDAP voting computers ( Memento from August 27, 2008 in the Internet Archive ) (PDF; 2.4 MB) from May 30, 2007.
- Use of voting computers unconstitutional press release of the Federal Constitutional Court.
- The biometric scrapbook. German Edition 2008 , in: Die Datenschleuder. The scientific journal for data travelers, No. 92, March / April 2008, p. 57,
- heise online: CCC publishes Wolfgang Schäuble's fingerprints on March 29, 2008.
- Zeit Online: “Schäuble's index finger hacked” from March 30, 2008.
- CCC: Chaos sets school. Retrieved January 11, 2016 .
- Anna Biselli: media literacy, quo vadis? Part III: Interview on the project “Chaos goes to school”. Retrieved January 11, 2016 .
- Tim Pritlove, Florian Grunow, Peter Hecko: CRE189 Chaos goes to school. Retrieved January 11, 2016 .
- Surveillance Trojan probably comes from Bavaria . In Zeit Online, notification of October 10, 2011; Retrieved October 10, 2011.
- Chaos Computer Club analyzes state Trojans . News from October 8, 2011 on ccc.de, accessed on December 28, 2016.
- Trojan affair puts Bavarian minister under pressure. Spiegel Online , October 11, 2011, accessed October 11, 2011 .
- Bavaria's Interior Minister stops the use of Trojans . Mirror online. October 11, 2011. Retrieved October 11, 2011.
- http://www.mz-web.de/servlet/ContentServer?pagename=ksta/page&atype=ksArtikel&aid=1319025291186&calledPageId=987490165154 .
- Software for evaluating the Bundestag election unsafe and vulnerable. Chaos Computer Club, September 7, 2017, accessed March 11, 2018 .
- Analysis of an election software. (PDF) Thorsten Schröder, Linus Neumann, Martin Tschirich, accessed on March 11, 2018 .
- SPIEGEL ONLINE: Health: This is how hackers got an electronic doctor's ID. Retrieved December 28, 2019 .
- CCC | CCC hacks the latest generation of hotel locks. Retrieved December 28, 2019 .
- Chaos Computer Club supports Chelsea Manning and Edward Snowden - online publication . CCC website. Retrieved August 28, 2014
- Pesthörnchen: The emergence of the Pesthörnchen ( memento from February 1, 2008 in the Internet Archive ) on Reinhard Schrutzki's website